Quote from: N'ZMAV on September 23, 2025, 05:29:56 PMQuote from: AV82EC on September 23, 2025, 05:27:26 PMIf we want to win or be challenging for the League (I know I know) he will have to be replaced. For a team in the mix for European qualification each season (ok maybe not this year) he’s more than adequate. I think there may be someone more suited to the EmeryVilla central striker role than Watkins but whilst he’s here and Emery doesn’t seem to want to change him then it’s utterly pointless speculating. agreed - our downfall is that when he's having a shite spell, we've got no real alternative And if we have an alternative, he's guaranteed to sulk.If Aston Villa were my sister and Watkins were her boyfriend, I'd tell her to thank him for the memories, move on and grow.
Quote from: AV82EC on September 23, 2025, 05:27:26 PMIf we want to win or be challenging for the League (I know I know) he will have to be replaced. For a team in the mix for European qualification each season (ok maybe not this year) he’s more than adequate. I think there may be someone more suited to the EmeryVilla central striker role than Watkins but whilst he’s here and Emery doesn’t seem to want to change him then it’s utterly pointless speculating. agreed - our downfall is that when he's having a shite spell, we've got no real alternative
If we want to win or be challenging for the League (I know I know) he will have to be replaced. For a team in the mix for European qualification each season (ok maybe not this year) he’s more than adequate. I think there may be someone more suited to the EmeryVilla central striker role than Watkins but whilst he’s here and Emery doesn’t seem to want to change him then it’s utterly pointless speculating.
Quote from: Sexual Ealing on September 23, 2025, 07:34:03 PMName someone then. Name ten of them. [sweating, furiously refreshing Football Manager] Uh, Jaime Tonbridge-Bort! Ahm, Nygard Bygard! Err let me see, er, Hydros Götterdämmerung! I'm sure there's more around here...
Name someone then. Name ten of them.
Quote from: KRS on September 23, 2025, 06:47:02 PMLet’s see how he gets on when we start playing decent football, remember how to attack teams and start creating chances for him. His touch can be frustratingly poor and he does miss his fair share of chances, but when he’s scoring and we’re winning again then his critics won’t be so vocal.You make it sound like when a goal scorer is scoring goals He doesn’t get criticism because he’s scoring goals.But when a goal scorer becomes a non-goal scorer and stops scoring goals he gets criticism for not scoring goals who’d have thought
Let’s see how he gets on when we start playing decent football, remember how to attack teams and start creating chances for him. His touch can be frustratingly poor and he does miss his fair share of chances, but when he’s scoring and we’re winning again then his critics won’t be so vocal.
I actually want to sign him now
And if we have an alternative, he's guaranteed to sulk.If Aston Villa were my sister and Watkins were her boyfriend, I'd tell her to thank him for the memories, move on and grow.
Quote from: john e on September 23, 2025, 08:08:30 PMI actually want to sign him nowHe won't help with our lack of directness. He just keeps the thing going around and around.
I think it's very possible to think that Watkins has been a very good player for us indeed, and also that he's not perfect, and that he's not irreplaceable. Our new sporting director (all praise to the sporting director!) picked up Isak for La Real when he was but a lanky young Swede with a dream and an ego - it is actually possible for recruitment to do their jobs well sometimes.