I don't think anybody's written him off, have they? Most people have just said he's not been at his best recently, and probably shouldn't be starting. He improved second half against Everton, and showed glimpses of what he's capable of.
On Saturday he had 3 very good carries with the ball, I don’t remember much else in terms of linking up, tackling or interceptions shots on target etc.Whilst I agree he has talent I don’t think his overall contribution is enough yet, but hopefully will develop into a top player.
I'd really like to see Emery try 4-2-3-1, as I think it would suit the likes of Ramsey much better than being stuck wide in a fairly rigid 4-4-2, as inMartinezCash Konsa Mings Digne/MorenoKamara LuizBuendia McGinn RamseyWatkins