John McGinn

[cdbearsfan]

Sanson? On the basis of what?

[ChicagoLion]

I don't think Mings was great Captain material, not vocal enough and too accepting of referees going against us.

[OCD]

First time I've seen Mings labelled as not being vocal enough. When there were no crowds, all I could hear was him shouting at players.

[Bent Neilsens Screamer]

I don't think Mings was great Captain material, not vocal enough and too accepting of referees going against us.

Not vocal enough…without him we’re virtually a team of mutes.

[Villa Lew]

I can see Gerard's reasoning but still a bit of a surprise, hopefully being captain will improve SJM's game.

[Beard82]

I would say Mings never hide, I think we lack leaders and he was one of the few that never gave up (though not saying he always concentrated).

I was expecting us to get in another player who would become captain. 

[villadelph]

I think its a decent decision and it will allow Mings to focus on his game instead of all the extra curriculars that come with being captain

[GordonCowansisthegreatest]

I can see Gerard's reasoning but still a bit of a surprise, hopefully being captain will improve SJM's game.

Having Kamara behind will improve SJM's game.

[Mortimer's Bear]

I don't think Mings was great Captain material, not vocal enough and too accepting of referees going against us.

Not vocal enough, really?

[OCD]

Arguably McGinn's best game last season was away at Palace when he had Nakamba doing the defensive work and was allowed to get forward.

[Clampy]

I don't think Mings was great Captain material, not vocal enough and too accepting of referees going against us.

Not vocal enough, really?

Yeah, bit odd really. He's very vocal.

[Clampy]

Feel a bit for Mings, but I remember saying on here around the time he first got the captaincy that I thought it might hinder his game slightly. Club Captain would have been a better call instead of Young. Pleased for McGinn though.

[jwarry]

Feel a bit for Mings, but I remember saying on here around the time he first got the captaincy that I thought it might hinder his game slightly. Club Captain would have been a better call instead of Young. Pleased for McGinn though.

Or maybe Gerrard doesn’t think he should be a regular starter?

[Meanwood Villa]

I can see Gerard's reasoning but still a bit of a surprise, hopefully being captain will improve SJM's game.

Apparently being captain has the opposite effect.

[pelty]

Apologies in advance for my ignorance, but what does the Club Captain role filled by Young do exactly?