Quote from: ChicagoLion on November 27, 2023, 05:32:22 AMIt was a piss poor decision for the card, it was a tackle he had every right to make.It wasn’t dirty, excessive or deliberate, a genuine attempt to win the ball and he caught the player slightly who made a meal of it.I can not remember him committing a foul before that. Awful ref.As the player had to be subbed off, I don't think he made a meal of it. It was a late challenge as the player played the ball faster then Cash anticipated, probably made slightly in frustration. As others have mentioned, it would be the classic challenge shown under the dictionary definition of Yellow Card Offence: Late Challenge Example.
It was a piss poor decision for the card, it was a tackle he had every right to make.It wasn’t dirty, excessive or deliberate, a genuine attempt to win the ball and he caught the player slightly who made a meal of it.I can not remember him committing a foul before that. Awful ref.
Quote from: Somniloquism on November 27, 2023, 09:06:49 AMQuote from: ChicagoLion on November 27, 2023, 05:32:22 AMIt was a piss poor decision for the card, it was a tackle he had every right to make.It wasn’t dirty, excessive or deliberate, a genuine attempt to win the ball and he caught the player slightly who made a meal of it.I can not remember him committing a foul before that. Awful ref.As the player had to be subbed off, I don't think he made a meal of it. It was a late challenge as the player played the ball faster then Cash anticipated, probably made slightly in frustration. As others have mentioned, it would be the classic challenge shown under the dictionary definition of Yellow Card Offence: Late Challenge Example.He's talking about Kamara isn't he? Which I felt was also fair enough. Their player was about to break past him and Kamara just stopped him. Sensible yellow card to pick up, and better to be out of the Bournemouth game than one of the two that follow it anyway.Obviously if he'd not done it, they'd only have got caught offside anyway.
Quote from: Dave on November 27, 2023, 09:16:12 AMQuote from: Somniloquism on November 27, 2023, 09:06:49 AMQuote from: ChicagoLion on November 27, 2023, 05:32:22 AMIt was a piss poor decision for the card, it was a tackle he had every right to make.It wasn’t dirty, excessive or deliberate, a genuine attempt to win the ball and he caught the player slightly who made a meal of it.I can not remember him committing a foul before that. Awful ref.As the player had to be subbed off, I don't think he made a meal of it. It was a late challenge as the player played the ball faster then Cash anticipated, probably made slightly in frustration. As others have mentioned, it would be the classic challenge shown under the dictionary definition of Yellow Card Offence: Late Challenge Example.He's talking about Kamara isn't he? Which I felt was also fair enough. Their player was about to break past him and Kamara just stopped him. Sensible yellow card to pick up, and better to be out of the Bournemouth game than one of the two that follow it anyway.Obviously if he'd not done it, they'd only have got caught offside anyway.Yes, missed the thread title so apologies for that. Everyone and their "Son" have been moaning about the Cash one that I genuinely thought it had been the only tackle in the games over the weekend. Edit:- Although the supposed elbow by Carlos on Gil, even shown on the Beeb for some reason seems to be gathering momentum in the media.
Quote from: Somniloquism on November 27, 2023, 09:22:55 AMEdit:- Although the supposed elbow by Carlos on Gil, even shown on the Beeb for some reason seems to be gathering momentum in the media. I didn’t notice that during the game. I think we were lucky that a pen wasn’t given. It was reckless by Carlos given that Gil was nowhere near getting to the ball.
Edit:- Although the supposed elbow by Carlos on Gil, even shown on the Beeb for some reason seems to be gathering momentum in the media.
Quote from: Somniloquism on November 27, 2023, 09:06:49 AMQuote from: ChicagoLion on November 27, 2023, 05:32:22 AMIt was a piss poor decision for the card, it was a tackle he had every right to make.It wasn’t dirty, excessive or deliberate, a genuine attempt to win the ball and he caught the player slightly who made a meal of it.I can not remember him committing a foul before that. Awful ref.As the player had to be subbed off, I don't think he made a meal of it. It was a late challenge as the player played the ball faster then Cash anticipated, probably made slightly in frustration. As others have mentioned, it would be the classic challenge shown under the dictionary definition of Yellow Card Offence: Late Challenge Example.Edit: forget it.
Blundered for tonight's goal but it didn't put him off his game the way early mistakes sometimes did last season.