Both Frank or Rodgers might do alright with us. Either of them will get more out of these players than Gerrard has been, so I'm confident we will get better under either of them.
Neither are exciting though, are they? Neither will make prospective players think "wow, Villa are going places I want to be a part of that". They are both managers that will steady the ship, but you can't imagine either of them really building something, which I think is what we need. Or, probably more accurately, what I want. I want excitement, this season so far is draining everyone of enthusiasm and we all need a lift. I'm not sure either of those would provide it initially. A team that wins more than once a month would certainly help though.