Matty Cash

[cdbearsfan]

Nobody was at fault. It was just jammy as fuck.

[Drummond]

Nobody was at fault. It was just jammy as fuck.

Quite.

[paul_e]

There was no major fault, a shot from 25 yards that's heading 2-3 yards wide but deflects into the over side of the net is just bad luck.

Maybe we could do things differently but from what I've seen the xG for the Shaw shot was 0.01 and the deflection was so low it rounded down to 0.00, it's a one in hundreds chance that just went the way of the spawniest bunch of wankers in the league.

[frank black]

Cash was the major fault for the goal conceded versus Man Utd. It was his missing the header
Poor positional play.
Not the first time he's been caught like this.

Eh? Hardly.

I enjoyed how Unai communicated with the players on the pitch. He was literally coaching Cash and others throughout. None of the John Gregory slagging off, Lambert incoherent rubbish or Gerrard nothingness. I was impressed, felt like the players appreciated it too. I think Cash will be just fine

[frank black]

Also I noted how he found an extra yard after the Polish Cafu chants.

[Footy-Vill]

Nobody was at fault. It was just jammy as fuck.

Quite.

There was no major fault, a shot from 25 yards that's heading 2-3 yards wide but deflects into the over side of the net is just bad luck.

Maybe we could do things differently but from what I've seen the xG for the Shaw shot was 0.01 and the deflection was so low it rounded down to 0.00, it's a one in hundreds chance that just went the way of the spawniest bunch of wankers in the league.

Yes there was
In the moments leading up to the goal, Cash missed a
crucial header, so in my opinion, that qualifies as a defensive blunder. I would also add that Ramsey's clearance wasn't particularly strong. Yes, the goal from the shot was fortunate, but we should focus on and consider what happened before the goal. People need to give bit more analysis and thought to the way the ball ultimately arrived go Shaw and that we conceded

Look, Cash failed to deal with the ball when it was crossed, as a result, it was his error of judgement that caused the ball to remain in possession of Man Utd in the danger zone. The ensuing play could have been avoided with a clearance.

There was a lack of composure and a sort of see it through to halftime attitude that allowed Manchester United to take control for the final 5 minutes of the half, where Villa had previously dominated.

Anyway, I hope it's clear what I'm emphasising is Cash failure and resulted in a goal as a result of Cash's inability to effectively clear the ball. That's how I see it, and it's here to debate Cash role. What's not the discussion is on Shaw's shot being deflected in as that is what is fortunate and that's in agreement by all.

[cdbearsfan]

You've emphasised it, people just disagree. The goal was no failure on anyone's part. Cash played his part in a famous victory, as did all the players, and I'm not sure why you're desperate to type paragraph after paragraph trying to find fault for a goal which was just pure luck, with Emi Martinez getting booked, or whichever other thing you've decided to bang on about today, rather than just enjoying the win.

[paul_e]

Nobody was at fault. It was just jammy as fuck.

Quite.

There was no major fault, a shot from 25 yards that's heading 2-3 yards wide but deflects into the over side of the net is just bad luck.

Maybe we could do things differently but from what I've seen the xG for the Shaw shot was 0.01 and the deflection was so low it rounded down to 0.00, it's a one in hundreds chance that just went the way of the spawniest bunch of wankers in the league.

Yes there was
In the moments leading up to the goal, Cash missed a
crucial header, so in my opinion, that qualifies as a defensive blunder. I would also add that Ramsey's clearance wasn't particularly strong. Yes, the goal from the shot was fortunate, but we should focus on and consider what happened before the goal. People need to give bit more analysis and thought to the way the ball ultimately arrived go Shaw and that we conceded

Look, Cash failed to deal with the ball when it was crossed, as a result, it was his error of judgement that caused the ball to remain in possession of Man Utd in the danger zone. The ensuing play could have been avoided with a clearance.

There was a lack of composure and a sort of see it through to halftime attitude that allowed Manchester United to take control for the final 5 minutes of the half, where Villa had previously dominated.

Anyway, I hope it's clear what I'm emphasising is Cash failure and resulted in a goal as a result of Cash's inability to effectively clear the ball. That's how I see it, and it's here to debate Cash role. What's not the discussion is on Shaw's shot being deflected in as that is what is fortunate and that's in agreement by all.

As ever you're over-analysing something so you can use it to back up an opinion you've already decided on. You've decided Cash will struggle under Emery and when people disagree you create some fantasy scenario to prove yourself right. I guarantee there isn't a single person at the club who's called him aside to discuss his 'major error'.

Listen, we cleared that cross and it fell to their left back who took a pretty poor effort at goal and a massive deflection completely changed it. The exact same play could happen a hundred times and we'd go in at half time 2-0 up in almost all of them. Even in the scenario where Shaw meets it on the volley so perfectly that it's in the net before Martinez moves it still wouldn't be because Cash made a mistake.

All you're emphasising is that Cash (and McGinn) are the players you've decided to shit post about for a while before you flounce off for another break because we don't all bow down to your genius insights.

[Tayls_7]

He'll be back with you soon. As ever, he's currently writing essays on ever other current thread going.

[tomd2103]

Thought he had a good game yesterday.  With Bailey in front of him for a lot of the game, the onus wasn't on him to provide attacking width and he had a good battle with their left winger, which he got the better of over the course of the game.

[Risso]

We had four people on the edge of the area, and the high, looping cross sailed over them all. Cash was closest, but he didn't miss the header, it was too high for him to get to. You might argue that Buendia could have got tighter to Dalot in the first place to prevent the initial cross, or Ramsey mught have booted the ball further up the pitch or into touch. But they weren't major errors, and 99 times out of 100 that shot goes harmlessly wide for a goal kick.

[Clampy]

Their goal was just unfortunate and very lucky. Blaming Cash is laughable, it's just absolute nonsense.

[Footy-Vill]

We had four people on the edge of the area, and the high, looping cross sailed over them all. Cash was closest, but he didn't miss the header, it was too high for him to get to. You might argue that Buendia could have got tighter to Dalot in the first place to prevent the initial cross, or Ramsey mught have booted the ball further up the pitch or into touch. But they weren't major errors, and 99 times out of 100 that shot goes harmlessly wide for a goal kick.

It's called positioning! Cash position and body shape to defend that wasn't right. Emery will see that.

[Footy-Vill]

Their goal was just unfortunate and very lucky. Blaming Cash is laughable, it's just absolute nonsense.

Actually it's just in my opinion, and was hoping more would be likely and willing to even consider an observation and careful analysis of the goal conceded. If not fair enough simply state that you disagree with it in you comment. I only ever want to encourage discussion but understand disagreement.

Emery will, in my opinion, be like Dean Smith's momentum and gain a lengthy winning streak that will propel us up the league. I wouldn't be shocked if we even won a cup this year!
I also wouldn't be shocked if Cash or McGinn didn't eventually become less important figures in the team.

[Risso]

It's called having an agenda. A boring, monotonous agenda.