The claret on the home shirt may not be the right claret according to traditionalists but its a nice sharp colour. I think its more fashionable than the traditional colour. The shirt is really good quality, nice thin, light material. Shame about the away one, I think they over complicated the collar area but I guess they will capture most peoples tastes across the two. I also fit in the small shirt which is a bonus! The proof will be its lastability though, Ive still got Nike shirts that have lasted better than the Macron ones....