0% Villa: Top Ten 'Overrated by Neutrals' in the Premier League

[hartman_1982]

Hasn't RVP scored something like 16 in 16 since January? I really rate him.

[eamonn]

If everyone's nominating Carrick - who I still think is a decent player, but nothing special - I'll throw his midfield buddy Anderson into the mix. What does he do these days?

Mark Kelly over-rates Anderson enough for the rest of us not to bother. 

And cdvillafan having another user-name...say it aint so?

[Rudy Can't Fail]

If everyone's nominating Carrick - who I still think is a decent player, but nothing special - I'll throw his midfield buddy Anderson into the mix. What does he do these days?

Mark Kelly over-rates Anderson enough for the rest of us not to bother. 

And cdvillafan having another user-name...say it aint so?

I keep telling you, this Ferguson fella knows nowt and he bloody bought him!

[JJ-AV]

I think Kalou is a little underrated. He scores one in three from wide and rarely starts. Really productive without headline grabbing.

[cdbearsfan]

If everyone's nominating Carrick - who I still think is a decent player, but nothing special - I'll throw his midfield buddy Anderson into the mix. What does he do these days?

Mark Kelly over-rates Anderson enough for the rest of us not to bother. 

And cdvillafan having another user-name...say it aint so?

I have only one username, but I share a PC with my brother... ADVILLAFAN, and forgot to log him off before posting.

[SoccerHQ]

Arshavin is a great shout

Who rates him?  He is known as an expensive flop to most is he not? 

He usually has a wonder game against us.

[SoccerHQ]

For someone in his first season in the prem, I think Carroll's been brilliant.

There's more to his game than just heading in crosses aswell, look at that goal he scored a few weeks back against Man. City.

Not overrated at all for me as on his day he can tear apart any defence in the prem.

[darren woolley]

I would say Adam,Taylor, and Henderson they are overrated these players don't appeal to me.

[pauliewalnuts]

For someone in his first season in the prem, I think Carroll's been brilliant.

There's more to his game than just heading in crosses aswell, look at that goal he scored a few weeks back against Man. City.

Not overrated at all for me as on his day he can tear apart any defence in the prem.

Do you think 35 million pounds is over the top?

[Dante Lavelli]

I think the public's perception of Carroll is about right. Hoeever the £35m fee is simply insane.

[joecrow]

ryan babel and johan elmander. dont see the point of either

[JUAN PABLO]

Joe Cole

[VillaZogmariner]

Theo Walcott

[JUAN PABLO]

Is Babel still at 'The Mighty Reds YNWA'? 

[VillaZogmariner]

Is Babel still at 'The Mighty Reds YNWA'?

No, they sold him in January. Think it was to Hoffenheim