Winter 24/26 transfer window - the verdict

[Toronto Villa]

I think it's 7. The upside is we moved Guessand on, got in Doug, Tammy and two promising young kids all while being fucked over by major injuries and highly restrictive PSR rules that forced our hand with Malen and scuppered the Gallagher deal at the start of the window. It's a shame we also didn't sort out Elliott. But in the grand scheme of what we could actually achieve I don't think we did that badly. With a bit of luck nobody else gets injured, we get Youri and SJM back and we finisht the season really well.

[brontebilly]

Guessand was a 0/10, might have been the worst player to play for us since we came back to the PL (Drinky aside). Any scout that identified him really shouldn't be working at the club any longer. 

Wasn't it reported that Guessand was an Emery pick?

The only one I ever saw talking up Guessand was Paul_e! Despite all evidence to the contrary too.

Emery gets credit for the signings that worked and Monchi the blame for ones that didn't. Same with Deano and that Suso dude. Truth likely somewhere in the middle.

[paul_e]

If you mean before he signed then I'm not sure how 12 goals and 8 assists isn't evidence that someone is worth a look. He hasn't settled, it happens but don't rewrite history to pretend anyone who thought he might be a decent signing was wrong.