The end product is where it's falling down for me.
The lack of bite, to put it mildly, in 50-50s is annoying, but I can see past that.
Conversely, I think he is genuinely focused and committed, and it also looks to me like he is enjoying his football with us (not just a nice to have; think of how painful it is to see Bailey suffering every game).
If he could add a burst of assists and goals...