He didn't play well but I never like the hyperbolic reactions to players. He worked hard, constantly tracking Mitchell, and isn't a coward or one of the worst players to play for us or whatever. He just isn't able to influence games enough. Palace are very physical, I am not sure it was the right game for him even if he was in form.
He was poor tonight - nothing seemed to come off for him.That said, and for balance, SJM was equally ineffectual.
Quote from: eye digress on January 07, 2026, 10:38:27 PMHe was poor tonight - nothing seemed to come off for him.That said, and for balance, SJM was equally ineffectual.Throwing John McGinn in for balance is a bit odd.
Quote from: Clampy on January 07, 2026, 10:40:20 PMQuote from: eye digress on January 07, 2026, 10:38:27 PMHe was poor tonight - nothing seemed to come off for him.That said, and for balance, SJM was equally ineffectual.Throwing John McGinn in for balance is a bit odd.Not really. Just observing their relative performances in the same game alongside one another.
Amazing how he’s out of form, lacking confidence blah blah blah.It’s seems to have dogged him his whole career since he came back from Germany.Or, just maybe he’s just a overhyped, overpaid fucking waster, stealing a living who has been bombed out by every team he has played for.
He is out of form and low on confidence. The manager is playing him and his teammates seem to like him. Given this team is successful, in part, because the players give every last drop, I doubt very much he is showing a poor attitude or lack of effort. A lack of confidence and a lack of effort can look very similar, I think the former is more his issue. Potentially alongside him just not quite having the level of talent to make up for his lack of physicality if a very tough league.As I said, not denying that he was ineffectual tonight and it's odd that he has been chucked in from the start in two very tough away games rather than at home. But I just think the 'doesn't care' and 'cowardly' accusations are wide of the mark.
Quote from: eye digress on January 07, 2026, 10:42:18 PMQuote from: Clampy on January 07, 2026, 10:40:20 PMQuote from: eye digress on January 07, 2026, 10:38:27 PMHe was poor tonight - nothing seemed to come off for him.That said, and for balance, SJM was equally ineffectual.Throwing John McGinn in for balance is a bit odd.Not really. Just observing their relative performances in the same game alongside one another.I think Mcginn (who scored two in.the last game) deserves the odd off game.