Jamal Jimoh-Aloba

[Sexual Ealing]

Slumming it in Smethwick has obv worked wonders for Illing Junior.   

Maybe we need to bring Mile back as loans officer.

Find our young talent good clubs and good scenarios.

I'd have thought that even a handful of 10-15 minute appearances for us in the topflight between now and the end of the season would be beneficial for Jimoh. Rather than semi regular appearances for the dregs of the lower division in front of pitiful crowds.

But then I have precisely zero domestic and European titles to my name, so what do I know.

Like Spurs would let anyone go, what with all the success they're having and have basically always had big club.

[Rudy Can't Fail]

Not sure a relegation battle would be great for his development, my mate reckons they were ultra defensive last time out although that might have been a 'horses for courses' reaction to getting gubbed 0-5 at home in the coaches first game.

We can surely place him at a better club than that shower.?

Exactly, even Coventry with their promotion attempt would back more sense, a team winning more often than not, trying to achieve something. Even Fat Frank may be able to help his development. But the Albion? It defies all logic.

[Garyth]

Not sure a relegation battle would be great for his development, my mate reckons they were ultra defensive last time out although that might have been a 'horses for courses' reaction to getting gubbed 0-5 at home in the coaches first game.

We can surely place him at a better club than that shower.?

Exactly, even Coventry with their promotion attempt would back more sense, a team winning more often than not, trying to achieve something. Even Fat Frank may be able to help his development. But the Albion? It defies all logic.

Counter argument*:

To grow, he needs to experience a range of challenging situations to allow mental and emotional maturity, while his body grows and 'hardens' in matches  where every decision matters. Experiencing a relegation battle will teach him a lot more than floating around the relatively protected youth and squad environment. Going to Coventry would put him in roughly the same position he is at Villa - struggling to get game time in a squad chasing top of the league.

At this point, the club know what his technical abilities are. We don't know enough about his metal, emotional, and physical durability -which can only be learned through experience.


*Not 100% sure I believe this, but I''ll put it out there in the interests of balance.

[OCD]

Perhaps he can tap-up any more promising youth players they might have.

[Clampy]

Got absolutely no problem with him going out on loan, it really does some players good. I'm not sure now is the right time though with us being short on numbers. Next season might be better.

[Mister E]

Got absolutely no problem.with him going out on loan, it really does some players good. I'm not sure now is the right time though with us being short on numbers. Next season might be better.

The most important criterion - in any loan - is that he gets loads of gametime. SIJ has had limited time; Barrie got effectively frozen out; Feeney's first-pick games have dried up, etc.
So, choosing the loan-club has to be done on their need for his talents as much as on the quality of their coaches.

[amfy]

Send him to PNE where I can keep an eye on him please!

[Tokyo Sexwhale]

West Brom look like they're in a relegation battle.  I'm not sure he's going to learn much of use there.

How many of these loans actually work out for our benefit, in that we get a developed player who can contribute to our squad, or increases their value, and we sell them for a tidy profit?

I'd rather keep him, especially with our injury problems, and him being a "free" player for the Europa League.  And he could win a medal.

[adrenachrome]

Not sure a relegation battle would be great for his development, my mate reckons they were ultra defensive last time out although that might have been a 'horses for courses' reaction to getting gubbed 0-5 at home in the coaches first game.

We can surely place him at a better club than that shower.?

Exactly, even Coventry with their promotion attempt would back more sense, a team winning more often than not, trying to achieve something. Even Fat Frank may be able to help his development. But the Albion? It defies all logic.

There is a long standing and understandable antipathy between supporters, but both clubs seem to get on well at coaching level, and are not averse to loans involving youth players.

[Rudy Can't Fail]

Not sure a relegation battle would be great for his development, my mate reckons they were ultra defensive last time out although that might have been a 'horses for courses' reaction to getting gubbed 0-5 at home in the coaches first game.

We can surely place him at a better club than that shower.?

Exactly, even Coventry with their promotion attempt would back more sense, a team winning more often than not, trying to achieve something. Even Fat Frank may be able to help his development. But the Albion? It defies all logic.

Counter argument*:

To grow, he needs to experience a range of challenging situations to allow mental and emotional maturity, while his body grows and 'hardens' in matches  where every decision matters. Experiencing a relegation battle will teach him a lot more than floating around the relatively protected youth and squad environment. Going to Coventry would put him in roughly the same position he is at Villa - struggling to get game time in a squad chasing top of the league.

At this point, the club know what his technical abilities are. We don't know enough about his metal, emotional, and physical durability -which can only be learned through experience.


*Not 100% sure I believe this, but I''ll put it out there in the interests of balance.

Ha! I get the character building etc even game time but he'd never see the ball at West Brom. Better to give him a book or two to build his character.

Amfy, would he get minutes at Preston? I've never been a fan of Paul Heckingbottom but haven't really given him any proper attention since he was at Leeds. I know he was decent at Sheff Utd but never came across as a Coach, more an old school Championship manager.

[PeterWithesShin]

Would he even get a good recption from the fans after ditching them for us a couple of years ago. We know how toxic it can get at a club that's shit and constantly losing.

[darren woolley]

If he does go out on loan I hope whoever he goes to look after him.

[Brend'Watkins]

Dobbin is already there, had a good start but you don’t hear too much about him lately. They also had Kesler-Hayden now at Cov. I’m not saying it’s where Villa careers go to die but it isn’t exactly an endorsement for a career progression. I like PNE though but for no particular reason.