Loan stars - Asensio / Disasi / Rashford - which will do best?

[pauliewalnuts]

It's a nice try, and not too far off, but not a full snookering of the threads, Footy.

[Footy-Vill]

I just wanted to comment on several things on several places. I’m open to suggestions especially during this period up to easter on how I can not annoy . Apologies if needs be as I was only musing and opening debate .

UTV!

[brontebilly]

I just wanted to comment on several things on several places. I’m open to suggestions especially during this period up to easter on how I can not annoy . Apologies if needs be as I was only musing and opening debate .

UTV!

Cheers, pal. Maybe a bit too early to tell on the three amigos. Mixed I would say so far but to be expected.

Garcia looks a real find, more for next season but a level above KN it seems.

Malen seems the odd man out of the Jan signings and has been unlucky not to get more minutes. He would surely have started at Cardiff if fit and well, should have come on much sooner v Brentford and no run at all at Palace was very strange.

Dont think he would have been signed if we knew Asensio and Rashford were coming a week later.

[dcdavecollett]

Was Malen ill for the Palace game, despite being on the bench?

[Footy-Vill]

Bravo to all 3 !

Rashford - assisting goals and contributions for the team . Earned and england call up

Asensio - 7 goals in 8 matches - absolutely wonderful as I suspected everyone adores him.

Disasi - Player of the match at Brentford , likely to start at PSG given he was rested , on yellow card , and only played few minutes

[Footy-Vill]

Marcus Rashford overtakes Asensio after yesterday!
He’s joined the party of 3 now on who is best signing .
Having watched the match on a re run this morning I felt Asensio was not so involved and Rashford took the penalty as he was having the better game.

[Grande Pablo]

Asensio was quiet yesterday, but is still a country mile ahead of Rashford on his contribution since arriving.

My wild unsubstantiated guess is we would fund all 3 signings with the sale of Cash (sadly, IMO), Digne (high wages), & one of Ramsey or Bailey.  I hope the latter, but fear the former given he'll count on the FFP balance.

[Somniloquism]

With how long Bailey has been here, I don't think there will be that much difference now on FFP, sale value might make the difference though.

[VillaTim]

Too early to say for any of them , but they are all bringing good stuff to the table .

[Footy-Vill]

Asensio and Rashy scoring tonight …. super stars the both of them!

[SaddVillan]

All 3 of them equally - in different ways

[VillaTim]

Being able to bring someone like Disasi on for the last 10 mins to shore things up is a real luxury.
Probably our best window ever.

[Chip Butty 111]

In all my years going down there I've never seen anyone with the combination of positioning, reading of the game, first touch and finishing who is better than Asensio. Rashford and Disasi have been great and have fitted in seamlessly, and Rashford has given us the benefit of being able to rest an overworked Ollie. Basically swapping Philogene for Malen was genius. We are a different animal since the January window.

[olaftab]

The difference with players like Asensio and Malen is the absolute precision when they take aim. They are the sort of top end players we have lacked in recent history.

[Footy-Vill]

Where are we in this debate ?
Asensio I see is only one starting matches but no end product ever since he missed those two penalties in one game.