Was it Hodgson who tried that for England before? Went with club form players from likes of Liverpool and it was a disaster. At least Southgate and Tuchel recognise you have to make a team out of the players. Form comes and goes. Not sure if leaving Foden at home counts as much of a statement, or TAA for that matter, but Tuchel is going to leave some better individuals at home. MGW is a very good player, tactically flexible and was mismanaged by some clown managers this season. He's in far better form than Rogers for some time.