Player Discipline, Bookings and Suspension

[Footy-Vill]

Card watch live: Newcastle
3 of the 4 starting midfield booked.

Some really poor barging tackle by McGinn tonight and got cautioned.
Kamara repeated offenses and was carded
Douglas Luiz showed ill disciplined and picked up another .
Our midfield is very talented but they really need to cut some of these things out as they'll be at 10 yellows and a two game ban soon.

7 cards
Kamara

6 Cards:
Douglas Luiz
McGinn

[Footy-Vill]

Of course Zaniolo main contribution is a yellow card add to his collection.
He and Duran have serious attitude issues.
That sort of low standards of discipline isn't for Emery Villa and not worth the space in squad.
Pretending he's hurt as worried he gets a yellow and sent off sums it all up.

[Toronto Villa]

Official for Aston Villa Newcastle
John Brookes. And that's a positive thing.

So much for your 'research'. He's given out 101 (ONE HUNDRED AND ONE) yellow cards and five reds in 23 games this season.

And we have never lost that's the positive thing

This aged well.

[Footy-Vill]

Official for Aston Villa Newcastle
John Brookes. And that's a positive thing.

So much for your 'research'. He's given out 101 (ONE HUNDRED AND ONE) yellow cards and five reds in 23 games this season.

And we have never lost that's the positive thing

This aged well.

I would make the same comments as Emery in defeat.
I'm proud of the record but it has to come to an end.

[Footy-Vill]

Official for Sheffield United : Paul Tierney
Overall record as Ref for Villa. one win 3 draws and 8 defeats
The match Villa won: Play Off Final Vs Derby

In 9 matches in the Prem
Villa have never won a Premier League match with Tierney as ref.
Drawn 2 lost 7.

[Footy-Vill]

Having our first defeat with John Brookes as official maybe it will balance things out to have our first Prem win with Tierney as official

[Risso]

It'll end up being a teensy bit more to do with whether we score more goals then Sheffield United or not.

[Drummond]

It'll end up being a teensy bit more to do with whether we score more goals then Sheffield United or not.

What claptrap. It's whether or not I wear the right combination of t-shirt, socks and pants.

[Footy-Vill]

Tierney Averages 1.93 Yellow Cards to an away team.

There are 5 Villa players who Average 1 or more fouls away from home in the league
Average Fouls per game away
Kamara 1.8
Luiz 1.5
McGinn 1.4
Zaniolo 1.3
Digne 1.1

Bookings away / Total Yellows
Kamara 4/7
Martinez 3/4
Watkins 2/4
Digne 2/5
Cash 2/5
Konsa 2/5
Luiz 2/6
McGinn 2/6
Zaniolo 1/5

[Footy-Vill]

Having our first defeat with John Brookes as official maybe it will balance things out to have our first Prem win with Tierney as official

A thumping first premier win with Tierney.
Also managed no bookings! Excellent work.

[Footy-Vill]

FA Cup Discipline
Brought in this season an automatic one-game ban for two bookings.
If a player is shown two yellow cards in FA Cup matches they will serve a suspension during the next match in the competition.
The slate is wiped clean after the quarter-final.

At risk of suspension:
 Bailey, Lenglet, Konsa, Cash, Tielemans, Zaniolo
Should we progress v Chelsea a booking for any of these 6 in Wednesday reply means not playing Vs Plymouth or Leeds in the next round.

[OCD]

Kamara's already on 7 bookings? He'll have a 2-game suspension before the end of the season at this rate.

[Footy-Vill]

The FA is to consider using the FA Cup to trial sin-bins for players who commit dissent or blatant tactical fouls.

The International FA Board (Ifab) is set to rubber-stamp the trials for sin-bins in professional football when it holds its annual meeting next month. It would give referees the power to send players off the pitch for ten minutes for cynical fouls or dissent towards match officials.

Sources have told The Times that the FA will seriously consider introducing the trial for the men’s and women’s FA Cups, but will need to work through the details of the protocols before making a final decision. The earliest it could be introduced into the competitions is next season.

[N'ZMAV]

they can't get simple decisions roght that have been in the game for decades, I have no hope for new ideas.

[Russ aka Big Nose]

they can't get simple decisions roght that have been in the game for decades, I have no hope for new ideas.

I don't like most/all of the tinkering with the game, though to be fair, sin bins have been tried in grassroots/youth football this season and the feedback is that it has worked.