Player Discipline, Bookings and Suspension

[Footy-Vill]

Manchester City v Aston Villa
Referee: Darren England.
Insight :
Did you know Emery Aston Villa discipline is fantastic at not conceding a penalty this season? The only club in the league.

Insight:
The appointed official has Given us 4 pens in 6 matches that he has officiated us in premier league
A total of 6 penalties in 11 games(championship included)

Gave one earlier this season V Palace -only match he's officiated us this season.

For Man City in 6 Prem matches officiated he's awarded 4 pens to them and 5 on total as gave Fulham a penalty as well as Man City  last season.
They haven't lost a match with him as ref in all 7 matches - 6 Prem 1 FA cup

Overall
He awarded 5 pens to Man City in 7 matches as he also awarded them a pen in FA Cup.
This season he's given 5 pens in 10 championship matches
And given two in 9 Premier matches as well as Villa he awarded a dubious one last match for Chelsea v Burnley. Very soft and sent off both the defender and Burnley manager!

Foresight:
A penalty will be awarded in Man City v Aston Villa match this evening based on the evidence.


Can we conclude Villa will be awarded the inevitable penalty or are we to see Grealish win a penalty ?

[Astnor]

With regard to Mcginns red card, important to note that he has exceptional intensity and aggression in his play and that he would not have been the same excellent player without it. Sometimes it spills over for him as for most but that happens seldom in his case really.

[Footy-Vill]

Is Luiz walking a tightrope with regards to number of yellow cards/possible suspension?

Yes very much so.
Luiz was an utter fool to push ball away for his last booking.
In fact a few of his 8 have been petulance. Annoying when so.

Just to inform again regards any player recieving 10 yellows  and games threshold of 32 games played.
It's up to and including, the 32nd game of the season a player will be suspended for two games

Yellow Cards Count with two matches and potential to be serve suspension
8:Luiz
Also to note Rodri is on 8 cards and that could influence how he plays.

[Footy-Vill]

With regard to Mcginns red card, important to note that he has exceptional intensity and aggression in his play and that he would not have been the same excellent player without it. Sometimes it spills over for him as for most but that happens seldom in his case really.

It's those charging fouls I can't stand. Can't get away with such nonsensical play. I'm all for passion but that style and sort of bustle is not Emery or my desire of how to retrieve a football.
Perhaps it's his Scotch heritage as it's not really a top 4 level player to be so wild. I guess it's his version of a tactical foul.
I can't stand Rodri fouls so at least McGinn isn't sneaky about what he's doing!

[Footy-Vill]

It's his first red card for us.

First offence ref / your honour doesn't cut with me.
We all know the rules.

The sooner Sin Bins come in the sooner these players will stop fouling.

[kippaxvilla2]

You’ve blown it with the no penalties awarded comments! Fair play to England he was the one that stuck to his guns on the Palace penalty decision.  The flip side being he’s the idiot that missed Liverpools onside goal against spurs.

[coreyfeldman]

It's his first red card for us.

First offence ref / your honour doesn't cut with me.
We all know the rules.

The sooner Sin Bins come in the sooner these players will stop fouling.

What the ever living fuck are you going on about. He knows the rules and has only received one red card. Just because you don't like a certain type of foul has nothing to do with the rules

You talk absolute shite mate

[OCD]

If you're going to predict we'll concede a penalty in the build-up to every match, the law of averages says eventually you'll be right. But it won't be because of foresight.

[Footy-Vill]

It's his first red card for us.

First offence ref / your honour doesn't cut with me.
We all know the rules.

The sooner Sin Bins come in the sooner these players will stop fouling.

What the ever living fuck are you going on about. He knows the rules and has only received one red card. Just because you don't like a certain type of foul has nothing to do with the rules

You talk absolute shite mate

It is not the first time he has committed such a foul where he's whacked an opponent even if he tends to get a yellow for it.  If he does it again and gets sent off, I believe that more people will think the same way I do. I just wonder why he did that foul in the first place. I think where you are, and some see it as oh, he has never had a red card before, but I would open the discussion to say that such a type of foul and lack of emotional control to get a red card at the magnitude and nature both in game and the impact of suspension in what trying to achieve champions league football well to me, there is no excuse.

Emery admitted that there was no bad intention and I agree and he said it was McGinn's second red card in 600 or so matches, but I believe Ginny should be more measured in his charging and barging around the pitch. Just before that red card he was fantastic at leading the battle, pressing and tackling lawfully and appropriately! It was inspiring and fantastic, so then he went and spoilt it all .What did he believe would happen? Konsa's gesture to the head suggesting 'think' was exactly this nonsense that you claim I've talking !

McGinn made a similar gesture when Kamara was sent off against Brentford, and I thought at the time I couldn't really respect that because Ginny isn't the one person to be saying composure.

The truth is that he's had to adapt and improve, and he'll have to continue to adapt and improve his football - look at his goal scoring this season, which is because he's been encouraged to be concerned about the football rather than the whole get stuck in approach. Yes, be passionate, but also exhibit some class.

Maybe you could also do the same in your foul language approach to someone who has a different view to you.

[coreyfeldman]

Yes obviously if he gets sent off more times then people will think he needs to get sent off more, this isn't insight or clever thinking on your part.

A big part of his game is in being aggressive and yes this leads to yellow cards and fouls sometimes but it's the way he plays the game. The red card was wreckless and stupid, agreed, but it is one.

Both dougie and kamara have more yellows than McGinn this season

i'd rather be accused of using foul language than constantly talking utter nonsense and fantasy like you our kid

[Footy-Vill]

If you're going to predict we'll concede a penalty in the build-up to every match, the law of averages says eventually you'll be right. But it won't be because of foresight.

I have not regularly predicted penalties . My research led me to a prediction that I made about penalties being awarded tonight, and I actually provided evidence and insight regards penalties and Darren England  I thought this was a good one to write home about as a foresight but seemingly can't please some people and instead a spin is made proclaiming I predicting a penalty to Villa every match.

I think you just don't want me this forecast to penalty awarding to be accurate as then have to find another stick to beat me with.

Let's focus on the key points raised ! I like to ask you if you don't want to encourage debate regards penalties and discipline at least don't discourage.

So it's to think about:
It's either a penalty may be granted today or not, and you can comment on the fact that Villa being only team that has not conceded a penalty this season.

I also highlighted and hoped it worth discussing  or people noting Darren England's penalty awarding record. That's the takeaway from my post for someone to discuss or think about. It's not really so kind try to break my heart or force a false narrative about me proclaiming penalty to Villa every match.
Personally I thought those facts were fascinating and it led me to conclude a penalty could well be awarded!

Anyway I hope you and everyone enjoys the game and that our team maintains a high level of discipline today!

Up the Villa!!

[Ads]

A lot of words that fail to explain away the fact he has had 1 red card for us.

[Footy-Vill]

Simplify then : it's principles.
And example.
First degree murder get mandatory life sentence.
Such a foul is a red card and three match ban.

[coreyfeldman]

Simplify then : it's principles.
And example.
First degree murder get mandatory life sentence.
Such a foul is a red card and three match ban.

Yes and he has been sent off once.

We are talking about football, not morality or murder or anything else. Just the rules of football and the fact that he has received one red card.

What is it that you can't grasp?

[Clampy]

Just block and if possible, dont re-quote him. Thanks.