The 1874 looks odd, other than that it's decent. I'd prefer no star but plenty like it so it doesn't bother me that much. Main thing is that the lion is facing the correct way and looks like a lion.
All in all, it’s not badCertainly better than the old one, and I reckon it’s better than the current round one
Hopefully this is the one they'll go with, not because it's any good or anything, but it will bring to an end one of the most tedious threads ever, and we can all go back to talking about FFP and amortisation.