I'd happily get rid of the star.
If you said to Juventus, Inter, Barcelona, or any genuinely big club, they should put a star in their crest to honor a specific trophy win, they'd say no because when they win it again it will just need changing again. That's the outlook a big club would have.
Not that I'm saying we aren't one, but we certainly don't act like it most of the time. It's alright Forest and Huddersfield having stars because they aren't going to win those trophies again and we all know it.
We probably won't win the CL again but at least don't admit defeat ffs.