Your all-time, ultimate Aston Villa line-up

[Fred Crump]

1960
1975
 
       Ron ( I’m sitting on the fence as to which one)

                          Bosnich
        Gidman Evans God Staunton
                   Mortimer Sid Barry ( nb must take the penalty)
                            Little
                         Shaw Gray
               

Subs :       Rimmer
                Southgate
                Swain
                Ian Taylor
                Milner
                Yorke
                Morley
               
       
                 

 

[Ads]

I thought it was players we had seen?

[PeterWithe]

1973

1983

Ron Atkinson

Mark Bosnich

Paul McGrath
Olaf Mellberg
Martin Laursen
Steve Staunton

Jack Grealish
Sid Cowans
David Platt
Mark Walters

Dwight Yorke
Gary Shaw

I’m harbouring a mild fear that I’ve completely forgotten some absolute shoeins, but there it is.

[Legion]

Tony Morley, for starters!

[PeterWithe]

I started going every week in 1985, he’d either left or faded. Walters gets in as he was the only one worth watching for years

[PeterWithe]

For a year or so Alpay was as good as there has been, rather spoiled his copybook mind

[Gareth]

I’ve stuck to players I’ve seen live with exception of Gary Shaw who blonde mop was the reason this Villa fan is a Villa fan whilst growing up in a family of noses.  Milner is the biggest omission

Birthdate - 17/10/1974

Started Supporting - 1979

Manager/Coach - Sir Graham

Keeper - Bosnich

Defender - Delaney

Defender - Southgate

Defender - McGrath

Defender - Staunton

Midfielder - Barry

Midfielder - Cowans

Midfielder - Grealish

Midfielder - Young

Midfielder - Platt

Attacker - Yorke

Subs

Keeper - Spink

Defender - Ehiogu

Defender - Mellberg

Midfielder - Townsend

Midfielder - Merson

Attacker - Saunders

Attacker - Shaw

Feel free to change the formation and post your all-time, ultimate Aston Villa line-up.

[PeterWithe]

I’m harbouring a mild fear that I’ve completely forgotten some absolute shoeins, but there it is.

I have, Gareth Barry for starters

[Fred Crump]

Me too, Des Bremner, Ray Graydon, Tony Daley, Dean Saunders, Dion Dublin, Merson, Grealish,  SJM, Laursen, Mellberg , Friedel, Ashley Young, and Alan Wright, to name but a few..
Oh , and Ashley Westwood of course.

[PeterWithe]

Me too, Des Bremner, Ray Graydon, Tony Daley, Dean Saunders, Dion Dublin, Merson, Grealish,  SJM, Laursen, Mellberg , Friedel, Ashley Young, and Alan Wright, to name but a few..
Oh , and Ashley Westwood of course.

Only one of those that i considered was Young

[cdbearsfan]

I considered Daley and Young. Ashley Young was one of the most exciting players we have ever had. Shame he ended up going on to become just a bit part player, usually out of position, for those twats. In fairness, he never got the respect he deserved from quite a lot of Villa fans, too. Certain segments of our support have a deep suspicion of flair players.

[Fred Crump]

Yes , there are certain players who because of either a) what club they go to  b) the lack of acknowledgement of Villa they give once they move on or c) being a tool the way they behave as a person don’t get the credit they deserve.
Young and Milner are a)
David Platt and Gareth Southgate are b)
Collymore Savo, Alpay and Hodge are c)
The snake is a mixture of a) and c)

[tony scott]

Right here goes.                                     Rimmer
                                        Gidman.                           Atkin
                                      Barry.         McGrath.       Evans
                                          Rioch.   Grealish. Milner 
                                               Yorke.       Mcparland      Sub. Bosnich  lynn Mcnaught  Mortimer Cahill  Withe Young

[tony scott]

Forgot Manager Mr Saunders

[tony scott]

1950
1959