Scott Hogan - retired

[paul_e]

Yep, Hogan with 10 goals in 61 games (mostly in the championship) certainly comes close to Wesley with 6 in 22, mostly in the premier league.

[VILLA MOLE]

we have no strikers and still we try to get rid , doesn't bode well for him

[Ad@m]

He's clearly not good enough for the Prem.  I bet he'd score hatfuls at Celtic though - crap defending and  the better quality players than Stoke have got creating the chances for him.

[Mossie Hennebry]

Are we sure that he's back? It looks like he started for Stoke U23s last night and scored.

[Drummond]

We wouldn't have him! He's still there.

[mr underhill]

The ultimate Brucie brain fart

[postal]

If we can recall him, then we need to, its that simple, as we don't have any forwards.

[Malandro]

If we can recall him, then we need to, its that simple, as we don't have any forwards.

Wrong thread.

[postal]

If we can recall him, then we need to, its that simple, as we don't have any forwards.

Wrong thread.

Why is this the wrong thread? It was a question about Scott on the Scott Hogan thread. If I have suggested something that can be shot down, then take aim. But its not the wrong thread.

[Mister E]

After having fired duds at Villa, ShueffU and Stoke, I don't see lil' Scottie as the answer to any of our current squad issues.

[Malandro]

If we can recall him, then we need to, its that simple, as we don't have any forwards.

Wrong thread.

Why is this the wrong thread? It was a question about Scott on the Scott Hogan thread. If I have suggested something that can be shot down, then take aim. But its not the wrong thread.

Sorry I thought you'd made a mistake.

[postal]

If we can recall him, then we need to, its that simple, as we don't have any forwards.

Wrong thread.

Why is this the wrong thread? It was a question about Scott on the Scott Hogan thread. If I have suggested something that can be shot down, then take aim. But its not the wrong thread.

Sorry I thought you'd made a mistake.

No worries, it wouldn't have been the first time 

And he still can have a role to play a villa, as unless I have missed something. we have no other forwards!!! 

[Jon Crofts]

If we can recall him, then we need to, its that simple, as we don't have any forwards.

Wrong thread.

Why is this the wrong thread? It was a question about Scott on the Scott Hogan thread. If I have suggested something that can be shot down, then take aim. But its not the wrong thread.

Sorry I thought you'd made a mistake.

No worries, it wouldn't have been the first time 

And he still can have a role to play a villa, as unless I have missed something. we have no other forwards!!! 

If he came back we’d still have no forwards.

[mr underhill]

worse still, we'd have an anti-forward.

[postal]

worse still, we'd have an anti-forward.

This is no different to the comments that I have made about Wesley when he was apparently 'playing' so I'll guess we'll disagree, that a less than perfect player is better than no player.
Yes, wrong thread.