He's poor. Simple as that. He came in with ideas and hasn't come remotely close to even beginning to impliment them.
One thing that blights our club and has done since Lambert, is the fact we're shockingly poor when it comes to individual errors. We gift goals. We gifted a penalty today. Again, some may argue it was harsh decision but the fact is Westwood, regardless of whether it's stone wall or not, puts himself in a position where he makes a challenge that runs the risk of giving away a penalty. Again, Westwood is one of those players who is just piss fucking poor at everything and makes sloppy errors.
Can you blame a manager on players making individual errors?
Yes you can. When the errors are as consistent as they are at Villa. Error upon error, fuck up upon fuck up. Why? Because the players for starters appear to have no idea how they are supposed to be playing. No one seems confident in what they are supposed to be doing. So on top of players looking confused on the pitch, they end up having brain farts and gifting goals.
That's Garde's fault and his problem, just as it was Sherwoods before him, and Lambert before that.
Is Garde an inspiring figure? Does he have the dressing room? No on both counts. Quite evidently the dressing room is split. There's no team spirit. No cohesion. No unity. The work-rate from the vast majority of players isn't good enough.
Does he make good decisions? No. His lineups, and subs are awful, even respecting the fact he inherited a poor squad. Tactically we're crap.
Fire his fucking arse. Pathetic. We've seen more than enough to realise he's never, ever going to get us moving in the right direction. Can you see Remi inspiring us for a long hard slog in the Championship? I can't.
We need another clean sweep in the summer and we need a manager who knows how to get out of the championship.