Quote from: PeterWithesShin on May 20, 2015, 02:53:52 PMOf course a player can be shit at one tournament and great at another. Any player at the top level can look world class for 6 games or look utter bobbins. You only have to look at Vlaar's hit and miss form for us as proof.I don't think good players to have such highs and lows. That they are shit for an entire tournament and then great another. I always find that great players just don't perform to their level like Messi as an example. With Vlaar though I certainly don't recall him being one of the worst players at the Euros. Because when we signed him people were generally pleased. Nobody said I can't believe we are signing one of the worst players from the Euros.
Of course a player can be shit at one tournament and great at another. Any player at the top level can look world class for 6 games or look utter bobbins. You only have to look at Vlaar's hit and miss form for us as proof.
Quote from: Toronto Villa on May 20, 2015, 03:22:15 PMQuote from: PeterWithesShin on May 20, 2015, 02:53:52 PMOf course a player can be shit at one tournament and great at another. Any player at the top level can look world class for 6 games or look utter bobbins. You only have to look at Vlaar's hit and miss form for us as proof.I don't think good players to have such highs and lows. That they are shit for an entire tournament and then great another. I always find that great players just don't perform to their level like Messi as an example. With Vlaar though I certainly don't recall him being one of the worst players at the Euros. Because when we signed him people were generally pleased. Nobody said I can't believe we are signing one of the worst players from the Euros. He was poor at that Euros, as were most of the Dutch which is why they finished bottom of their group with zero points. You really don't think a player can play well above, or below, his ability for a 3-6 game period?
Make your mind up, you just said they couldn't I never said he was one of the worst, so you should ask that to whoever said he was. I was simply pointing out that a player can be shit at one tournament and great at another.
Quote from: PeterWithesShin on May 20, 2015, 03:43:37 PMMake your mind up, you just said they couldn't I never said he was one of the worst, so you should ask that to whoever said he was. I was simply pointing out that a player can be shit at one tournament and great at another. My point was being shit and performing below par are not the same thing.
Quote from: Toronto Villa on May 20, 2015, 03:47:44 PMQuote from: PeterWithesShin on May 20, 2015, 03:43:37 PMMake your mind up, you just said they couldn't I never said he was one of the worst, so you should ask that to whoever said he was. I was simply pointing out that a player can be shit at one tournament and great at another. My point was being shit and performing below par are not the same thing. Rooney was top class at a Euros and has more often than not been shit at every other tournament. It does happen to players.
Quote from: Percy McCarthy on May 20, 2015, 01:25:06 AMQuote from: Toronto Villa on May 20, 2015, 01:16:35 AMVlaar was one of the worst defenders at the Euros? We talking the same bloke who received worldwide plaudits for keeping Messi quiet for an entire game? That's the Lionel Messi by the way who is arguably the best player in the game today.You know Messi can't play at the Euros right?this reminds me of when Christian was on fire early on in his Villa career...a West Ham fan in our village said that when Benteke fucks off to the Africa Cup of Nations...we'd be fucked... UTVThe Doc
Quote from: Toronto Villa on May 20, 2015, 01:16:35 AMVlaar was one of the worst defenders at the Euros? We talking the same bloke who received worldwide plaudits for keeping Messi quiet for an entire game? That's the Lionel Messi by the way who is arguably the best player in the game today.You know Messi can't play at the Euros right?
Vlaar was one of the worst defenders at the Euros? We talking the same bloke who received worldwide plaudits for keeping Messi quiet for an entire game? That's the Lionel Messi by the way who is arguably the best player in the game today.
Sherwood mentioned Vlaar (and Okore) have been playing through injuries the past couple of games. The Vlaar one is news to me but puts into perspective his Southampton performance.
Quote from: ciggiesnbeer on May 22, 2015, 05:43:16 PMSherwood mentioned Vlaar (and Okore) have been playing through injuries the past couple of games. The Vlaar one is news to me but puts into perspective his Southampton performance.Is it really a surprise though?
Tim Sherwood: Ron Vlaar is staying at Aston VillaSherwood confirms he has held talks with Vlaar and expects the Holland international to sign a new contractTim Sherwood has revealed that Ron Vlaar is ready to sign a new contract with Aston Villa.Sherwood has confirmed he has held talks with Vlaar and expects the Holland international to stay at the club beyond this summer.Earlier this year Vlaar seemed certain to leave on a free transfer, with Southampton and Napoli both considering moves at the end of this season.But the appointment of Sherwood has revitalised the 30-year-old and he is now ready to discuss a new deal after Villa secured their Premier League status last weekend.Sherwood said: “I’ve told Ron I want him to stay and he’s said he wants to.“His representatives are going to talk to the club and I’m confident something can be done. Are we close? Well put it this way, we’re not a million miles away.“He’s a man who is quite rightly in demand but I can see him being here next season. He’s indicated to me that he’s happy and I’m thinking exactly the same way, so I’m sure it will get done.“Ron’s going to have a lot of options. He’s not long come back from a World Cup where he had a really good tournament.”Vlaar was signed from Feyenoord for £3.2million in 2012 and has been club captain, though he was replaced as skipper by Fabian Delph earlier this year.
Quote from: Toronto Villa on May 20, 2015, 03:22:15 PMQuote from: PeterWithesShin on May 20, 2015, 02:53:52 PMOf course a player can be shit at one tournament and great at another. Any player at the top level can look world class for 6 games or look utter bobbins. You only have to look at Vlaar's hit and miss form for us as proof.I don't think good players to have such highs and lows. That they are shit for an entire tournament and then great another. I always find that great players just don't perform to their level like Messi as an example. With Vlaar though I certainly don't recall him being one of the worst players at the Euros. Because when we signed him people were generally pleased. Nobody said I can't believe we are signing one of the worst players from the Euros.Plenty raised concerns at the time of his signing due to his injury problems and also his hopeless performance at the Euros before he joined. It looked like our defence in Lambert's first season would include Given, Vlaar and Dunne. The three of them would have been in a worst X1 at Euro 2012.