Barry,Milner,Young and Downing

[QBVILLA]

Hypothetically speaking if we had the opportunity to re-sign one of them in January who would you choose if any and why? Fees/wages irrelevant for the sake of the question.

I'd opt for Barry as I think he'd best strenghthen the team and would prove an ideal midfield partner to Ireland whilst also adding much needed experience to the side.

[PaulTheVillan]

None.

Messi.

[not3bad]

Fantastic!  I could talk on this subject until Christmas 2013.

[Barney74]

Milner, without a shadow of a doubt...

[Darlo Dave]

Agree with Barney74, Milner. Don't even need to think about it.

[tomd2103]

As it stands, Barry would be an ideal fit in the current team alongside Westwood.

[Andy_Lochhead_in_the_air]

Maybe Milner - we so miss his all action work ethic
Maybe Young - we so miss his quality out wide.
Maybe Barry - we so miss his creative quality in midfield.
 
Anybody who says Downing is taking the piss.

[N'ZMAV]

Milner. In the middle of the park.

[andyh]

Barry.

Downing can fuck himself

[eamonn]

These threads are very depressing.  Anyway --> Barry then Young.
Downing and Milner much the same. They've been out of form since they left us, maybe they were only one season wonders.

[ozzjim]

Milner, by a long stretch. None of the others have come close the homage to Milner thread, and to be able to resurrect that would be a joy.

[l_mckay]

Think it would be Barry for me,would add some much needed experience in the middle.

[villan1975]

Young as there is a complete lack of somebody who can beat a player or do something a bit different. As a team we need
somebody more like Barry though. Can we have our lord back whilst we are at it?

[eastie]

Milner by a distance.

[silhillvilla]

Why torture yourself