He isn't good enough yet. Being loud and American isn't the same as commanding a box. Hes hit and miss on crosses and his kicking is only slightly better than bosnichs. One of many players who are not good enough.
neither are good enough imo
No. He isn't good enough to be a first choice. He is a handy back up keeper who's good at penalties, but I don't see him being number 1 long term so I wouldn't persevere with him in the medium term. I think Given deserves a chance to rediscover some form.