Aston Villa v Wigan Athletic Match Thread

[citizenDJ]

Good tackle from Hutton. Hope he improves quickly - he really needs to.

[timeoutbigbar]

I realise i'm in a minority, but I think Hutton has been ok today.  I stress ok, not excellent.

[pr_N'villa]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

He gets sold more times than a dodgy car.

I know its early days,but with money tight,he seems like a player we didn't need to buy,not with Herd,Cuellar,even bloody Beye is on a par with him.

when we bought Hutton, Cuellar and Lichaj were out (and still are), Herd had just got injured and that left us with Beye. Young wanted to leave so we couldn't just remain with Beye.

Now they're virtually all fit,apart from Lichaj,and were stuck with this useless tube.Feel sorry for Herd as it'll reduce his chances. The money should've been saved for a rainy day.

Herd is a natural midfielder not a right back, so we needed an experienced right back and hutton was the best available

[ozzjim]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

Have to say, I normally don't like to write players off, but Hutton thus far looks like one of the worst players we've had for a long time.

I've already said it, but it's worth repeating. Hutton is shit and so is Jenas, if you factor in his unreliability.  Complete waste of money.

Will judge Jenas when we see him play. As I said, Hutton needs a few months but signs are not great.

[TheSandman]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

Have to say, I normally don't like to write players off, but Hutton thus far looks like one of the worst players we've had for a long time.

I've already said it, but it's worth repeating. Hutton is shit and so is Jenas, if you factor in his unreliability.  Complete waste of money.

We really should have bought a defensive midfielder instead.

[pauliewalnuts]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

He gets sold more times than a dodgy car.

I know its early days,but with money tight,he seems like a player we didn't need to buy,not with Herd,Cuellar,even bloody Beye is on a par with him.

when we bought Hutton, Cuellar and Lichaj were out (and still are), Herd had just got injured and that left us with Beye. Young wanted to leave so we couldn't just remain with Beye.

Now they're virtually all fit,apart from Lichaj,and were stuck with this useless tube.Feel sorry for Herd as it'll reduce his chances. The money should've been saved for a rainy day.

Herd is a natural midfielder not a right back, so we needed an experienced right back and hutton was the best available

Really? Hutton was the best right back, of all those we could have signed?

Hmmm.

[TheSandman]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

He gets sold more times than a dodgy car.

I know its early days,but with money tight,he seems like a player we didn't need to buy,not with Herd,Cuellar,even bloody Beye is on a par with him.

when we bought Hutton, Cuellar and Lichaj were out (and still are), Herd had just got injured and that left us with Beye. Young wanted to leave so we couldn't just remain with Beye.

Now they're virtually all fit,apart from Lichaj,and were stuck with this useless tube.Feel sorry for Herd as it'll reduce his chances. The money should've been saved for a rainy day.

Herd is a natural midfielder not a right back, so we needed an experienced right back and hutton was the best available

We should have signed that Luke Young fellow.

[pauliewalnuts]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

Have to say, I normally don't like to write players off, but Hutton thus far looks like one of the worst players we've had for a long time.

I've already said it, but it's worth repeating. Hutton is shit and so is Jenas, if you factor in his unreliability.  Complete waste of money.

Will judge Jenas when we see him play. As I said, Hutton needs a few months but signs are not great.

Hutton looked equally rubbish at Spurs, too, though. He looks disturbingly like a case of "looks good in Scotland, but ..."

[pr_N'villa]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

He gets sold more times than a dodgy car.

I know its early days,but with money tight,he seems like a player we didn't need to buy,not with Herd,Cuellar,even bloody Beye is on a par with him.

when we bought Hutton, Cuellar and Lichaj were out (and still are), Herd had just got injured and that left us with Beye. Young wanted to leave so we couldn't just remain with Beye.

Now they're virtually all fit,apart from Lichaj,and were stuck with this useless tube.Feel sorry for Herd as it'll reduce his chances. The money should've been saved for a rainy day.

Herd is a natural midfielder not a right back, so we needed an experienced right back and hutton was the best available

Really? Hutton was the best right back, of all those we could have signed?

Hmmm.

name one experienced right back, at a price we could have afforded?

[pauliewalnuts]

How bad is Hutton, seriously shit.  Out of position constantly and can't cross for toffee.  Awful.

He gets sold more times than a dodgy car.

I know its early days,but with money tight,he seems like a player we didn't need to buy,not with Herd,Cuellar,even bloody Beye is on a par with him.

when we bought Hutton, Cuellar and Lichaj were out (and still are), Herd had just got injured and that left us with Beye. Young wanted to leave so we couldn't just remain with Beye.

Now they're virtually all fit,apart from Lichaj,and were stuck with this useless tube.Feel sorry for Herd as it'll reduce his chances. The money should've been saved for a rainy day.

Herd is a natural midfielder not a right back, so we needed an experienced right back and hutton was the best available

Really? Hutton was the best right back, of all those we could have signed?

Hmmm.

name one experienced right back, at a price we could have afforded?

I don't need to - I'm asking whether of all the right backs around, whether Hutton was the best, and finding it hard to think he was.

How about not selling Luke Young? In fact, how about playing Herd? Or Beye?

[Brian Taylor]

Any links that actually work?? tia

[PaulWinch again]

Great effort Banna.

[ozzjim]

Oooo nice from Bannan.


Hutton dodges ANOTHER penalty bullett

[Edvard Remberg]

Hutton crap

[citizenDJ]

Hmmm. We still are playing too deep, in my opinion. I suppose that's how McLeish wants it (and MON always seemed to ask the team to sit very deep, too), but it means that we give so much ground to the opposition when they get the ball. They always seem to be able to just walk forward towards our penalty area.

Still, we're looking good enough today.....for now.