I concede that if there was no gambling then racing wouldn't exist although I regularly watch races not having had a bet because I love to see the horses in action but while racing continues, their welfare must be the priority. It cannot be described as a blood sport such as hare coursing because there is no deliberate cruelty and aside from Saturday's unedifying spectacle, in general terms horses are very well treated. They are bred to jump but if they don't want to race they won't. There are a number of notable horses who refuse to race from time to time and I love to see that.
I've long been a proponent of a whip ban, it should only be held in the hand to steer the horse, if you're having to hit the animal you've immediately lost your argument.
I can see why there are calls for an outright ban and I can see why people would like it to continue but large sections of the racing community need to knowledge that the scenes on the first circuit in the National do far more damage to the sport than anything else and if they don't, then the calls for a ban, along with the direct action of the type we saw on Saturday will continue to a much greater extent.