Quote from: peter w on November 11, 2010, 02:06:26 PMThe batting does worry me as the cupboard is bare. I would venture that Cook and Collingwood are there by default, and for all his good work over the past couple of summers trott is only a poor run from being dropped as i am unsure whther he is good enough to play against the top bowling attacks. poor last winter - after a promising start - and this winter will make or break not only his international career and its longevity, but will make or break ENgland's current batting ability.Any player is only a poor run away from being dropped. I think that Trott has the mental strength and technique to deal with the Aussies. It's Cook that concerns me. He's been woefully out of touch for some time now. If they dispense with him then Trott moves up to open and Morgan slots in. I think that Morgan has the sort of unorthodox technique that could prove useful.
The batting does worry me as the cupboard is bare. I would venture that Cook and Collingwood are there by default, and for all his good work over the past couple of summers trott is only a poor run from being dropped as i am unsure whther he is good enough to play against the top bowling attacks. poor last winter - after a promising start - and this winter will make or break not only his international career and its longevity, but will make or break ENgland's current batting ability.
Quote from: Villan For Life on November 11, 2010, 08:40:55 PMQuote from: peter w on November 11, 2010, 02:06:26 PMThe batting does worry me as the cupboard is bare. I would venture that Cook and Collingwood are there by default, and for all his good work over the past couple of summers trott is only a poor run from being dropped as i am unsure whther he is good enough to play against the top bowling attacks. poor last winter - after a promising start - and this winter will make or break not only his international career and its longevity, but will make or break ENgland's current batting ability.Any player is only a poor run away from being dropped. I think that Trott has the mental strength and technique to deal with the Aussies. It's Cook that concerns me. He's been woefully out of touch for some time now. If they dispense with him then Trott moves up to open and Morgan slots in. I think that Morgan has the sort of unorthodox technique that could prove useful.I would go the opposite way. I would tell Cook he's in for the series. If he fails this time i'd drop him next summer, this way his replacement would have a chance. England have to often chopped & changed & panicked in Australia, this time let's take a deep breath & go with what we've got, review performances at the end & make changes accordingly.
"love to see Aussies prepare for next Ashes series by playing England A in Stornoway. Come on ECB."Direct quote from Simon Mann on twitter.
Anyone been watching Swanny's Ashes Video Diary on Youtube? Much fun!