Ok second half I guess after a frankly disgusting performance in the first half. 4 subs tells its own story. We can all quibble with the odd selection decision or sub but:- without Cash we went through three different right backs today- our best midfielder was at LCB and had a nightmare- Tielemans a 10, playing at 6 again where he's a liability- Watkins limping off unsurprisingly after 9 games in last month, no striker in reserve to come on- likes of Rogers and Tielemans clearly fatiguedMonchi has not given Emery much of a chance here. I couldn't stand Carlos but playing 2 x PL games and1 x CL game with one fit centre back is ridiculous. Martinez 6 - beaten too easily for the goal but stopped first half being a routGarcia 3 - crazy decision to start him in that back 4, lost Konsa 2 - I'm not sure what has happened to turn him into one of the most dislikeable Villa players I can remember. A responsibility dodging pr*ck today starting with the first ball that came his wayKamara 3 - nightmare first half exposed him out of position. At fault badly for first and nearly anotherDigne 5 - far from the worst but Bellegarde caused a lot of problemsBogarde 5 - utterly lost in first half but reasonable defensive shift in second at RBTielemans 5 - tidy with ball usually but a liability without it in that position.McGinn 6 - at least played like it was a derby, getting stuck in but not much quality where it matteredRogers 4 - fatigue obviously and issue at this stage but ball retention was really weak today. Didn't seem up for the physical duelsRamsey 1 - awful in just about everything he did. First touch needs huge work. Attitude all wrong. Watkins 4 - struggling anyway with his hold up play and limping clearly for 5-10 mins before half timeMaatsen was decent enough I thought, Bailey started well, got kicked a few times and hid then, Onana is a dud, Malen isn't a 9 but few times he spun to left he looked decent. Ned was ok in likely his last appearance for us.
Quote from: Gareth on February 01, 2025, 07:58:06 PMOfficials wrecked the game with that disallowed goal…disgusting decisionIt was horrible i agree but we should ahve been 3 down at half time. The performance was not acceptable
Officials wrecked the game with that disallowed goal…disgusting decision
You can have a checklist of nearly every away performance this season... the home team work hard, shut off the avenues and impose their gameplan on us...go one down to the first shot they have and then we look increasingly more inept.. halftime...a bit of juggling, better performance without barely laying a glove on them. Rinse and repeat. We're gonna finish about 9th/10th like this..We need something different for a lot of these aways...the controlling , measured approach has been counteracted by a lot of opposition now..Again, hardly any of the front 5 held it up or did anything meaningful... fatigue is a factor. I'd rather we had changed it and had Ramsey, Rogers to come on after their efforts midweek...Felt for Garcia and he probably would have benefited from coming off the bench too..all hindsight but think we all knew this would be a tight game with the Dog heads pressing us, especially in the first half as every ferker seems to do.
Quote from: brontebilly on February 01, 2025, 07:56:03 PMOk second half I guess after a frankly disgusting performance in the first half. 4 subs tells its own story. We can all quibble with the odd selection decision or sub but:- without Cash we went through three different right backs today- our best midfielder was at LCB and had a nightmare- Tielemans a 10, playing at 6 again where he's a liability- Watkins limping off unsurprisingly after 9 games in last month, no striker in reserve to come on- likes of Rogers and Tielemans clearly fatiguedMonchi has not given Emery much of a chance here. I couldn't stand Carlos but playing 2 x PL games and1 x CL game with one fit centre back is ridiculous. Martinez 6 - beaten too easily for the goal but stopped first half being a routGarcia 3 - crazy decision to start him in that back 4, lost Konsa 2 - I'm not sure what has happened to turn him into one of the most dislikeable Villa players I can remember. A responsibility dodging pr*ck today starting with the first ball that came his wayKamara 3 - nightmare first half exposed him out of position. At fault badly for first and nearly anotherDigne 5 - far from the worst but Bellegarde caused a lot of problemsBogarde 5 - utterly lost in first half but reasonable defensive shift in second at RBTielemans 5 - tidy with ball usually but a liability without it in that position.McGinn 6 - at least played like it was a derby, getting stuck in but not much quality where it matteredRogers 4 - fatigue obviously and issue at this stage but ball retention was really weak today. Didn't seem up for the physical duelsRamsey 1 - awful in just about everything he did. First touch needs huge work. Attitude all wrong. Watkins 4 - struggling anyway with his hold up play and limping clearly for 5-10 mins before half timeMaatsen was decent enough I thought, Bailey started well, got kicked a few times and hid then, Onana is a dud, Malen isn't a 9 but few times he spun to left he looked decent. Ned was ok in likely his last appearance for us. Some poor marks there, but I still think you've been generous to a number of our players
Bad as we were, we probably would have won had our perfectly legal goal been allowed.
Quote from: Demitri_C on February 01, 2025, 07:59:47 PMQuote from: Gareth on February 01, 2025, 07:58:06 PMOfficials wrecked the game with that disallowed goal…disgusting decisionIt was horrible i agree but we should ahve been 3 down at half time. The performance was not acceptableWe were poor but we weren’t 3 down at half time because their chances weren’t taken which happens….the officials made a dreadful decision that they had no right to get wrong…would have made a completely different game for last half hour
When your own people sabotage the team then you are going to struggle.A shocking indictment of Monchi was shown under the Molineux lights tonight.Two days of the transfer window left with opposition clubs knowing we are desperate so can inflate transfer fees accordingly.Utterly ridiculous, self-inflicted wounds.
Quote from: Bobby Boy on February 01, 2025, 08:14:16 PMWhen your own people sabotage the team then you are going to struggle.A shocking indictment of Monchi was shown under the Molineux lights tonight.Two days of the transfer window left with opposition clubs knowing we are desperate so can inflate transfer fees accordingly.Utterly ridiculous, self-inflicted wounds.Can't disagree. This is the angriest I have been in two and a half years.