Tim Sherwood vs Gary Rowett

[El Mayor]

Who is the better manager? And do you think he would do a big Eck and defect if he was offered the Villa job?

[Goldie.7]

What's that smell?

[Legion]

The Villa one.

[PeterWithesShin]

I vote for the one that likes Villa.

[damon loves JT]

Both of them are unproven at their current level. But even if Rowett aces the whole season, it doesn't mean he could cut it in the Premier League. Plenty of managers have looked like world-beaters in the second division, taken a step up and done nothing. We could all name half-a-dozen off the top of our heads.

[oswald funkletrumpet]

i like both sherwood and rowett, not convinced by either of them yet. a full season for both and then ill have a better idea

[aj2k77]

Who loves the Villa more? Rowett or Sherwood? Probably Rowett until Tim's won something with us.

[pauliewalnuts]

Who cares?

Although Rowett is, like us, a proper Villa fan by birth, whereas Sherwood is new Villa.

[PeterWithesShin]

[pauliewalnuts]

El Mayor is a that lot.com person.

It'll obviously take him a while to get used to a forum with fewer threads about Villa than he's used to, and some of the clever, big words will be confusing to start with, but I'm sure he'll settle in quite nicely.

[PeterWithesShin]

No shit Sherlock (Street).

[FrankyH]

Who are more obsessed with Villa ,  albion or small heath ?

We could count up the number of new members who join this site before each respective game  pretending (badly) to be Villa fans.

[aj2k77]

Who better to manage Obsessed with da Villa Fc than a Villa fan? I bet he loves it, hearing Villa mentioned every minute of the day.

[Dante Lavelli]

To be fair, he's hardly come on here and abused us or the club.  To ask who we think is the better manager is reasonable and i suspect the second question is borne out of fear that IF Rowett is good then at some point we'd try and poach him due to his original allegiance (and many other reasons).

[Stirchley Villain]

I'd always back a Villa fan.