Carlos Sanchez

[brian green]

I thought he was very poor against QPR. Many slow players are very good players but to me he needs to be coached not to get hot headed when he makes a mistake. You can see that he wants to compensate for errors but it makes him give away silly free kicks. He will improve when he feels more settled.

[Tony Erdington]

Youre sign in should be Nice Brian, from Nice France,

he was bloody awful tuesday Brian, but only today was I told that Keiran Richardson was at fault for at least the first and the third goals, my excuse for not seeing that was the sacred Heart and the fact that I was in the lower Holte and I mean the lower Holt, and the friend that explained it to me was in the lofty upper holt good over view of the pitch.

So although I thought Sanchez was poor my peer advises me Richardson beat him to the wooden spoon for the qpr game.

all the best

[brian green]

Trying to be nice Tony. Have upset a few people lately. Consensus of opinion is that Richardson was unfit/unwell.

[aj2k77]

Trying to be nice Tony. Have upset a few people lately. Consensus of opinion is that Richardson was unfit/unwell.

He's been a bit shit even when he's fully fit though hasn't he to be honest. I don't rate Richardson at all.

[KRS]

I'm not one to be negative or overly criticise our players but Sanchez really is a walking liability. Having watched the Man City game back again, and apart from the good finish for his goal, there's really not a lot that he brings to the team so I can only think that he's the best of a bad bunch to play as the holding midfielder.

I'm sure some could argue that he breaks up play, but he's consistently giving away possession when it should be a simple pass or mistiming tackles and giving away free kicks...either way he seems to cause more pressure on our back four rather than doing his job to relieve it.

His sending off at Tottenham may well have turned out to be a blessing as TS was forced to shuffle the pack and found a way to play without him. I'm really not sure if he'll make the cut as a Premier League footballer, and I'd rather not have this liability in the team at the moment...but what other options do we have other than Westwood in the middle of the park?

[Matt Collins]

I'd play Westwood against Everton

[dekko]

I like Sanchez, but like KRS said the good work that he does (specifically breaking up play - I think his positioning is very good) tends to be undone by the aformentioned loose passing and reckless tackling.

However, I think the old chestnut about some foreign players taking time to adjust to the pace of the league might apply here, so I wouldn't be looking to offload just yet.

[Phil from the upper holte]

I think there is a good player in there, definitely would not offload

[silhillvilla]

Too slow and far too many dreadful errors in key areas. I'd give him til Xmas to improve if not it's an offload in my view .

[tom jennings III]

It is such a key position that he does have to improve quickly to keep his place in my opinion. I hope he does as I think he is a good player and hungry to win but he just has to cut out some of the silly errors and poor passes. Simple stuff so I'd definitely be interested to see what sort of improvements are made after a proper pre-season with Sherwood and the new coaching staff. I'm not sure who else would be available at our price range that would be an instant improvement.

[Boz]

I think there is a good player in there, definitely would not offload

It seems Sherwood rates him though, and that's what matters, not what the fans opinions are 

[PaulWinch again]

I think he's a good player for 65 minutes of a game and then makes terrible errors thereafter. It's pretty obvious from that, that either his fitness needs to be worked on or he needs to be subbed around that time each game.

[LeeB]

I'd play Westwood in his role every time.

[OCD]

Too slow and far too many dreadful errors in key areas. I'd give him til Xmas to improve if not it's an offload in my view .

Glad that wasn't our attitude with Petrov.

[Kingthing]

I know fuck all about most things but I reckon he'll turn out to be a very good player.