Transfer Speculation / Gossip

[Villafirst]

Can't Keano call on a favour from his Old Trafford contacts? Like Hernandez on-loan? Here's a conundrum: would you swap Vlaar for Hernandez if Van Gaal comes calling?

[johnny from donny]

No

[Smirker]

Can't Keano call on a favour from his Old Trafford contacts? Like Hernandez on-loan? Here's a conundrum: would you swap Vlaar for Hernandez if Van Gaal comes calling?

Not a straight swap, no.

[mr woo]

IF we could shift Bent on for a nominal fee, bearing in mind he is one of the top earners, I wonder if there'd be sufficient funds to take a punt on someone like Loic Remy?

[Clampy]

Can't Keano call on a favour from his Old Trafford contacts? Like Hernandez on-loan? Here's a conundrum: would you swap Vlaar for Hernandez if Van Gaal comes calling?

Not with Bent there and Benteke and Kozak to come back, no i wouldn't.

[Chipsticks]

Can't Keano call on a favour from his Old Trafford contacts? Like Hernandez on-loan? Here's a conundrum: would you swap Vlaar for Hernandez if Van Gaal comes calling?

God no, I personally don't buy into the myth that we need more strikers.

[claret and blue blood]

the singlemost important signing for me now is Vlaar on a 4'year deal.He's our captain and a great leader on and off the pitch,the message to the rest of our team and the rest of the football world would mean that we have turned a corner,the opposite appliesif we sell him.If week sign one more ,and Lambert has said he wants one more,it has to be a creative player.

[barrysleftfoot]

 I would yes.Hernandez is top top quality and 25, Vlaar is 29.No brainer for me.

[PaulWinch again]

No for me, we need Vlaar.

[Havencheese]

the singlemost important signing for me now is Vlaar on a 4'year deal.He's our captain and a great leader on and off the pitch,the message to the rest of our team and the rest of the football world would mean that we have turned a corner,the opposite appliesif we sell him.If week sign one more ,and Lambert has said he wants one more,it has to be a creative player.

Yes.

Add to that the fact that the guys actually look like a unit, a bunch of blokes who look like they enjoy playing together. Richardson, Hutton, Senderos they all looked the part in those celebrations and they've only been together a matter of months or weeks even. Re-sign Concrete Ron for the sake of this new found unity.

[edgysatsuma89]

I would yes.Hernandez is top top quality and 25, Vlaar is 29.No brainer for me.

This. Not much point in discussing this though.

Shit i am.

[Toronto Villa]

I'd much sooner we kept things tight at the back and worked ways to score goals with what we have then sell our captain.

[Des Little]

Before yesterday I was open to selling Vlaar for big money however after watching how well him and Swiss Phil worked together there's no way I'd let him go. Quite the opposite in fact...give him a 3 year deal.

[garyshawsknee]

No for me, we need Vlaar.

This. We need him far more than an other striker.

[Chris Smith]

I would yes.Hernandez is top top quality and 25, Vlaar is 29.No brainer for me.

If he was 'top quality' why would he be available to a team who have struggled for 3 years?

As it happens, I think he's a decent enough player but not I doubt we figure in his reckoning and he doesn't play in a position that is a particular priority for us. Add in the wages he will be looking for and it is a total non-starter in my view.