Alan McCafu

[pbavfckuwait]

I know Hutton is very limited, especially in his ability to cross a football, but I can't hate the man as at least (I know 45k a week minimum requirement) he tries, there are still and have been alot of blood suckers here at Villa Park (CNZ, Ireland etc) who have not even offered that.

[Matt Collins]

I don't hate him

He's just shit

[frank black]

I enjoy watching him, there is a perverse pleasure seeing him receiving the ball in loads of space on the wing. Space afforded to him by the opposition as their manager has said "don't worry about Hutton". I am just hoping that one day his marauding pays off.

[Lastfootstamper]

STOP BEING SHIT.

[eddiemunster]

STOP BEING SHIT AND STOP WEARING A VILLA SHIRT FFS!!!

[wittonwarrior]

Not enough just to give 110% you need some ability to play league football enough said

[Toronto Villa]

Awful player

[ChicagoLion]

Adomah spent most of the game bailing him out.

[godzvilla]

Then there's this ( from the Mirror) and  having checked 3 seperate 'Player Ratings' for todays game , Hutton came out reasonably  well , which tallies with what I saw , admittedly , on TV, but  hey!.... I guess we always need to find whipping boy ......................Godzvilla!
Johnstone 7
Impressive start for the on-loan keeper, confident and commanded his box.
Hutton 6
Got forward on occasion, solid defensively and had a decent game.
Chester 7
Good clearance from Son’s cross shot. Had a steady, defiant game.
Baker 6
Had a good ding-dong battle with Janssen, did well for Villa.
Amavi 6
The busier of the two full backs as Son’s pace often stretched him.
Adomah 6
Clumsy, careless in possession and ran out of gas. Frustrating.
Tshibola 6
Strong and physical in midfield, gets stuck in. Determined display.
Jedanik 6
Disciplined midfield display, just sat resolutely in front of the defence.
Grealish 7
Everything went through him in Villa’s midfield. Lively and good set pieces.
Bacuna 6
Tried to push on from the left flank, had limited openings.
Agbonlahor 6
Thrown a lifeline by Steve Bruce, worked hard, went close but denied.

[Phil from the upper holte]

He's an ok defender but he should never be allowed to cross the halfway line, absolutely bollocks at going forward

[ASHTONVILLA]

He's an ok defender but he should never be allowed to cross the halfway line, absolutely bollocks at going forward

He is pretty good going forwards until he put in the cross. He gets into good attacking positions quite a lot, then frustrates with the final ball. At least he makes the chance to get the ball in, if he could make the final ball he would be one of our better players. Pity, as he puts a shift in and can defend (which is more than you can say about Amavi who also does little with the final ball).

[paul_e]

He really can't defend.  He had a good first half yesterday because he didn't have anyone to mark.  2nd half they pushed Sissoko (and later nkoudou) onto him and they ripped him to pieces.  He can defend if all it means to chasing back and getting a last ditch tackle in, he has absolutely no ability to mark a player who knows how to run and his concentration levels are abysmal.

[wittonwarrior]

Possibly one of our 5 worst players ever to wear a Villa shirt

[Ad@m]

Possibly one of our 5 worst players ever to wear a Villa shirt

Behave!  I doubt he'd be one of the worst 5 players of the Lerner era.

[chrisw1]

Possibly one of our 5 worst players ever to wear a Villa shirt

Behave!  I doubt he'd be one of the worst 5 players of the Lerner era.

Arguably he's not one the worst 5 players in our current squad.  (Elphick, Cissoko, Westwood, Gardner, Richards, Agbonlahor, Kozak, Bunn and arguably on current form McCormack!)