Carruthers? I didn't even realise he was playing! Is he on the left?
I agree that donacien has looked quite good. Would be more defensive but seems a much better bet than herd or the guy at left back.
Gardner seems quite like his brother at that age. Great shot and set piece. Really poor on possession under pressure. Hopefully that will improve. But he strikes me as a testimony to why England fails to produce Spanish style midfielders. you can get through to a high standard at 21 on the basis of physique and certain attributes, without having had to really learn to play one and two touch under pressure