Villa's Fab 50 Top Players

[Legion]

13: Andy Gray

[frankmosswasmyuncle]

13: Andy Gray

Tbh i think he is the most exciting player I've ever seen in a Villa shirt!
He scared defences shitless and was so confident that he was gonna score and did!
I used to love driving home after the game with my mate Dave and Villa fan after Villa fan phoning up Tony Butler and crooning to him: "Hey Tone, what about the Villa? Andy Gray's great" and Butler simply had no response, week after week. We had the best striker in the league and everybody knew it! The good old days!

[GJH]

Paul Mcgrath, Ian Taylor & Dwight Yorke should be top 3.They've never been replaced!

Never saw him play but ive been told Gary Shaw aswell.

[Legion]

Gary Shaw was my boyhood hero/idol.

[Legion]

Regardless, here is a far better summation:

Richard Whitehead in The Times

[Legion]

Paul Mcgrath, Ian Taylor & Dwight Yorke should be top 3.They've never been replaced!

Never saw him play but ive been told Gary Shaw aswell.

You need to look deeper into our history.

[GJH]

yea maybe but they are 3 top candidates!

Cant think of many better defenders? Yorkie is still the leading prem goalscorer and Ian Taylor is just Ian Taylor - legend!

Each to his own, i can only comment on what i think

[Big Dick Edwards]

Paul Mcgrath, Ian Taylor & Dwight Yorke should be top 3.They've never been replaced!

Never saw him play but ive been told Gary Shaw aswell.

Ian Taylor, one of our top three players of all time?! Good grief!

[The Left Side]

Sid should be in the top 5!

[VillaAlways]

12: Gareth Barry

[pedro25]

13: Andy Gray

Tbh i think he is the most exciting player I've ever seen in a Villa shirt!
He scared defences shitless and was so confident that he was gonna score and did!
I used to love driving home after the game with my mate Dave and Villa fan after Villa fan phoning up Tony Butler and crooning to him: "Hey Tone, what about the Villa? Andy Gray's great" and Butler simply had no response, week after week. We had the best striker in the league and everybody knew it! The good old days!

You could argue we have the best striker in the league now, well not far off surely.  Ian Taylor was a workhorse, but top 3 of all time, no where near.  Barry at 12 is a disgrace.

[dave.woodhall]

They didnīt include Nigel Simsī nickname. Cant think why.

[Dave Cooper please]

Barry at 12 - Sir Brian at 25.

Enough said.

[TheSandman]

BARRY??? Our twelfth greatest player ever?

Christ on a fucking bike.

[The Left Side]

Barry at 12 - Sir Brian at 25.

Enough said.

Exactly Dave, who is coming up with this!