The game would have been at Coles Lane, Sutton Town. Either 1967 or 68.
I went to a few old stars games at this time. I may even have some small programme/ teamsheets which you bought to get your admission.
Name: Haynes, Arthur Edwin Thomas
Birthdate: 1924-05-23 in Birmingham (Died: 1990-07-04)
Position: Forward
Playing for Villa: August 1945 (as an amateur) - June 1948
Previous clubs: Birmingham Schoolboy football, joined 70th Battalion Royal Warwickshire Regiment (WW2), Paget Rangers
Signed: - From Paget Rangers
Sold: - To Walsall
League: 4 matches - 0 goals
Cup: 0
International:
More info:
He signed professional in January 1946.
https://www.astonvillaplayerdatabase.com/608.html