Brentford vs Aston Villa Post-Match Thread

[cdbearsfan]

It was offside with the naked eye, IMO. No complaints from me.

[edgysatsuma89]

It was offside with the naked eye, IMO. No complaints from me.

Yeah, I ran in from the kitchen and said it straight away watching the replay. Went back and ate a bhaji, didn't bother to wait for the decision.

[The Edge]

Offside is offside regardless of the measurement. The technology isn’t 💯 accurate but it is what it is.

Yes it's a guess.

[ADVILLAFAN]

Thought all our Defence did well. Shout out to Digne, as I can't remember Mbuemo being so quiet in a game before.

Seemed to go off a bit when JJ was subbed.

[The Edge]

It was offside with the naked eye, IMO. No complaints from me.

I haven't actually seen any of today's game. My problem with VAR is more of a general one.

[Brazilian Villain]

Warning : Contains images that VillaTim may find distressing.

Spoiler for Hiden:

[VillaTim]

Offside is offside regardless of the measurement. The technology isn’t 💯 accurate but it is what it is.

Yes it's a guess.

It's not accurate at all , allows them to spin what narrative they want on these incredibly tight ones . If that's your liverpools / ManUres it's a goal

[edgysatsuma89]

The amount of shit decisions that would be made by linos if it went back to how it was would be incredible. You think they're guessing now? What they're guessing on is between 2 frames and what looks most likely as to when the ball is released. Your watching in 24 fps per second, I imagine those deciding are dealing with the same, so between those 2 frames is 0.04 seconds. That guess just isn't making that much of a difference.

[VillaTim]

It was offside with the naked eye, IMO. No complaints from me.

It wasn't .

[The Edge]

The amount of shit decisions that would be made by linos if it went back to how it was would be incredible. You think they're guessing now? What they're guessing on is between 2 frames and what looks most likely as to when the ball is released. Your watching in 24 fps per second, I imagine those deciding are dealing with the same, so between those 2 frames is 0.04 seconds. That guess just isn't making that much of a difference.

Really? Have you actually watched them moving the frames trying to decide which one to use? It absolutely does make a difference. Linesmen have to make split second decisions in real time so there's obviously the potential for the occasional error. Sitting in the comfort of a studio watching monitors is totally different. When they bought in VAR in the first place we were told it was there to stop the "clear and obvious errors" How can it be a clear and obvious error when they're manipulating tv frames forward and backwards and come to the conclusion that someone's toenail or nasal hair was offside?

[olaftab]

Offside is offside regardless of the measurement. The technology isn’t 💯 accurate but it is what it is.

We are where we are.

[Percy McCarthy]

I was arguing with some numpty on twitter the other day who didn’t accept the provable fact that Konsa and Mings are our best defensive CB partnership. I eventually broke his spirit with the tweet: “Konsa and Mings once kept a clean sheet WITH OLSEN IN GOALS’!’

Now it’s twice.

Of course, as everyone surely knows, it always helps playing a good defender at right-back instead of Cash.

[edgysatsuma89]

The amount of shit decisions that would be made by linos if it went back to how it was would be incredible. You think they're guessing now? What they're guessing on is between 2 frames and what looks most likely as to when the ball is released. Your watching in 24 fps per second, I imagine those deciding are dealing with the same, so between those 2 frames is 0.04 seconds. That guess just isn't making that much of a difference.

Really? Have you actually watched them moving the frames trying to decide which one to use? It absolutely does make a difference.

I have seen them do it. Do you think they're thinking, 'I'll move this 0.04 seconds forward to shaft the Villa'? They're just not. And like I said, the level of guessing from actual linesman in real time is infinitely more. Loads of people would be claiming corruption for the big clubs way more than they are now, it would be even less transparent. They would get away with far, far more.

[chipper]

Defence was excellent, delighted for Olsen.
The new “Worlds No1”
Bailey- copy and paste!
Rodgers taking too much out of it.
Rashford so so really.

[Dave]

I was arguing with some numpty on twitter the other day who didn’t accept the provable fact that Konsa and Mings are our best defensive CB partnership

Jesus, I didn't realise you'd taken this crusade beyond these shores.

Hiring a billboard on the A34 might mean you don't need to take so much time over it?