Villa’s best XI

[eye digress]

We've conceded 9 in 7 in the Prem, 10th in the defending table , nothing mythical about that .

In last few matches, we have played the long ball a lot more. Possibly because Diego Carlos not as comfortable on the ball as other defenders.

Possibly also because Carlos strikes a mean long pass with little backlift (talking distance here, he doesn't have the passing quality of Torres, obvs).

Also, don't we play three at the back anyway, when in possession?

[Mister E]

It depends on the opposition and circumstances, but this would be a lovely thing to behold:
                      Martinez
             Konsa   Mings    Pau
Nedeljkovic     Kamara       Maatsen
    Ramsey    Tielemans    Rogers
                   
                      Watkins

[colin69]

Mings (if fit) would be in my starting line up if at all possible.
We have a very decent squad now with players coming back. It’s so difficult to name a starting eleven when everyone is available.

[ChicagoLion]

Yes we already play 3 at the back which is very different to the silly idea of wing backs.
The reason He doesn't do wingbacks is because it reduces the flexibility and fluidity of tac tics and game management.

[Brend'Watkins]

Mings (if fit) would be in my starting line up if at all possible.
We have a very decent squad now with players coming back. It’s so difficult to name a starting eleven when everyone is available.

Mine too. His clearing headers are sorely missed. He also gives us a more calming feel at the back.

[Astnor]

Martinez
Konsa, Carlos, Pau, Digne
McGinn, Onana, Tielemans, Ramsey
Rogers,
Watkins

[edgysatsuma89]

Martinez
Konsa, Carlos, Pau, Digne
McGinn, Onana, Tielemans, Ramsey
Rogers,
Watkins

If Kamara gets back to his best, then he is a definite starter.

[Percy McCarthy]

We've conceded 9 in 7 in the Prem, 10th in the defending table , nothing mythical about that .

6 in 4 without Carlos, 3 in 3 with.

[ASHTONVILLA]

Our defence is mid to lower table level in terms of goals A . Mings cannot come back soon enough .

Since Carlos came back in, in 4.5 games against Young Boys, Ipswich, Wolves, Manure & Bayern, we’ve conceded 3 goals.

That is a really good stat. He gets pelters and I am never that confident he wont make a mistake, but we do seem to be better with him in the team and Konsa at right back. Mings was the same, always prone to a error but his presence always coincides with us being more solid.

The defence misses Kamara and any of our potential back four options will be better when he is back in the team.

[Tayls_7]

It depends on the opposition and circumstances, but this would be a lovely thing to behold:
                      Martinez
             Konsa   Mings    Pau
Nedeljkovic     Kamara       Maatsen
    Ramsey    Tielemans    Rogers
                   
                      Watkins

Imagine discussing a best XI without SJM and Bailey amongst many others. That's some strength in depth now.

[Footy-Vill]

It depends on the opposition and circumstances, but this would be a lovely thing to behold:
                      Martinez
             Konsa   Mings    Pau
Nedeljkovic     Kamara       Maatsen
    Ramsey    Tielemans    Rogers
                   
                      Watkins

Imagine discussing a best XI without SJM and Bailey amongst many others. That's some strength in depth now.

I agree I am not sure if I would put McGinn or Onana in the best 11. For me, Kamara and Tielemans would be ahead of them as midfielders. Also, if it's the best eleven, Duran AND Watkins are a serious consideration for both but that's another debate in itself!

However, as you say about depth , having so many alternatives is fantastic! Nedeljković listed here but I dunno if he would even make the bench with all squad to choose from.

But in any cup final this season, I can see McGinn and maybe even Onana starting! That is why it is so difficult to select a best 11 outright.

This discussion is super interesting, as is viewing everyone's different lineups.

[Mellin]

Okay, we've all seen enough football this season. Let's go.

                    Martinez
Cash   Konsa    Torres    Digne
             Onana  Kamara
Bailey      Tielemans     Ramsey
                   Watkins

OR

                       Martinez
          Konsa    Mings     Torres
Cash       Onana      Kamara      Maatsen
             Tielemans   Ramsey
                        Watkins
             

[coreyfeldman]

Okay, we've all seen enough football this season. Let's go.

                    Martinez
Cash   Konsa    Torres    Digne
             Onana  Kamara
Bailey      Tielemans     Ramsey
                   Watkins

OR

                       Martinez
          Konsa    Mings     Torres
Cash       Onana      Kamara      Maatsen
             Tielemans   Ramsey
                        Watkins
           

352 is illegal and you'll be hunted down and killed for this

[Ads]

I'm not sure, but I'm certain it's never had the chance to play together yet.

I'd like to see;

Martinez

Cash
Konsa
Torres
Maatsen

JJ
Onana
Kamara
Rogers

Tielemans
Watkins

[Mister E]

                       Martinez
          Konsa    Mings     Torres
Cash       Onana      Kamara      Maatsen
             Tielemans   Ramsey
                        Watkins
 
 This for me, with Nedeljkovic pushing Cash for the RWB role, Rogers intercahngeable with Ramsey and Barkely pushing Tielemans for a slot.