Villa players out on loan and out permanently

[Ron Manager]

baker hasnt pulled any trees up at bristol

robinson likewise and is now back at preston

gardner injury prone and back at a mid table side where he has been before

they all need to be shipped out permanently

On the contrary Baker is popular with the Bristol City fans,they like him. Robinson,who quite a lot of us rated,seems to be regressing at a great speed.Lets hope he gets his career back on track at Preston.

[garyshawsknee]

The young lad at Wolves, Graham I think, is he on loan or did well sell him ?

[Ron Manager]

The young lad at Wolves, Graham I think, is he on loan or did well sell him ?

I think we sold him. Doing very well at the moment.

[oswald funkletrumpet]

He did.  I would have sooner played Gardner at the weekend to see if he was any use to us. I hope it means at least one midfield player is on the way in to the club.

totally agree

im not sure why the likes of kinsella, gardner, hepburn murphy, lyden havent been tried

then you look at donacien who is 22 and has been on loan for a season and a half and is playing in league two. cant understand what we are getting out of this

[garyshawsknee]

The young lad at Wolves, Graham I think, is he on loan or did well sell him ?

I think we sold him. Doing very well at the moment.

That's a shame, seen him a couple of times on the telly and looks to have something about him.

[oswald funkletrumpet]

baker hasnt pulled any trees up at bristol

robinson likewise and is now back at preston

gardner injury prone and back at a mid table side where he has been before

they all need to be shipped out permanently

My Brother-in-Law, a City Season Ticket holder and a gent who knows his football, thinks Baker has done extremely well (the odd brain-fade apart) and he says that's a view shared by those around him. There's plenty to complain about there but Baker isn't one of them.

so baker doing well at a club who are in the bottom 3 of the championship is good for us in what way?

[Dave]

Just that it's better than if he were doing badly for a club in the Championship bottom three.

[PeterWithe]

The young lad at Wolves, Graham I think, is he on loan or did well sell him ?

Sold him. My Wolves mates reckon he's been different class the last 10 games and are resigned to losing him. One described him as the best player they've had there for 5 years, which struck me as a little premature.

[frankmosswasmyuncle]

I'm surprised Kinsella hasn't been tried at left back considering the problems we've had in that position. With the return of Cissokho and Bennett he's bound to slip down the pecking order. A shame.

[sirlordbaltimore]

Where's Bennett these days ? i'm sure loaned him rather than sold him

[AVH87]

Well one man we had on loan but don't anymore is Tiago Llori, most pointless signing ever, not played a minute of football, he's returned to Liverpool.

[Villa in Denmark]

Where's Bennett these days ? i'm sure loaned him rather than sold him

Recalled from Bournemouth at the same time as Cissokho.

[RussellC]

I don't think we even sold Jordan graham did we? I'm pretty sure we gave him away.

[Gareth]

In Gardners defence, he did very well at Forest 2nd half of last season and was the victim of a horror tackle at Swindon in pre-season - can't really be put down to a injury prone on that one, can happen to anyone!

Would like to have seen him play at Wycombe :-(

[Woofles The Wonder Dog]

baker hasnt pulled any trees up at bristol

robinson likewise and is now back at preston

gardner injury prone and back at a mid table side where he has been before

they all need to be shipped out permanently

My Brother-in-Law, a City Season Ticket holder and a gent who knows his football, thinks Baker has done extremely well (the odd brain-fade apart) and he says that's a view shared by those around him. There's plenty to complain about there but Baker isn't one of them.

so baker doing well at a club who are in the bottom 3 of the championship is good for us in what way?

My point  was that you confidently asserted he wasn't "pulling up any trees" at Bristol, but he is, at a level we'll soon be experiencing unless the sun starts rising in the west. There's plenty of actual stuff to be negative about without making it up.