Which former player would you bring back?

[DeKuip]

All the other clubs on there elect to bring back a legend who's no longer playing and we get someone who was desperate to come back to us last summer but we didn't want him!

I'd say we need a decent attacking full-back right now - and we've had some good ones in the past to choose from.

[nick harper]

A leader - anyone from:-

Peter Withe
Dennis Mortimer
Allan Evans
Martin Laursen
Gareth Southgate
Andy Townsend

[PaulTheVillan]

Peter Whittingham

[Zhong Yi]

George Cummings.

apparently he man marked Stanley Matthews out of a big FA cup match when Matthews was in the middle of his 20 years of prime.

[Can Gana Be Bettered!?!?]

Dwight Yorke.

[rick1944]

With out doubt James Milner is the player we need most,why didnt big eck go for kranjar instead of Jenas ?

[pedro25]

Milner.

[glasses]

Yorke for me

[PeterWithesShin]

Sid.

[Holte L2]

Current - James Miner.

All time, Paul Mcgrath

Can we re-sign Big Ron as manager too?

[darren woolley]

All time would be God.

Still Playing Ashley Young.

[Damo70]

Still playing, Ashley Young.

One from the past, I'm torn between Paul McGrath to sort the defence or Tony Morley to create and score goals. ( Dennis Mortimer to lead from the middle wouldn't be a bad idea either.)

And I'm guessing the Albion fan who said Richard Sneekes was quite young and has only been going for about ten years surely?

[Big Dick Edwards]

If it's limited to player still playing and given our current defensive weakness, would it be too controversial to suggest a certain defender at Bolton?

Suggesting a return for Zat Knight is possibly even more ridiculous than for Thomas Hitz!

[bertlambshank]

Gary Penrice everytime a true Villa legend.

[E I Adio]

I know my dad would have said Billy Walker.

I think the player who has possibly brought me most joy is Sid.

Beyond Milner and Ash, I can't think of anyone who is still playing that I'd bust a gut to get back.