Would much prefer to see Cuellar play there.
I don't recall Cuellar coming as close to giving away penalties and getting sent off as often as Hutton has managed to do this season.
Quote from: TheZogman on October 23, 2011, 04:34:41 PMI don't recall Cuellar coming as close to giving away penalties and getting sent off as often as Hutton has managed to do this season.Hutton's played almost every game for us this season and hasn't given any pens away or been sent off as far as I can recall. In fact, he's only had two yellows in all those games which isn't too bad for a defender in the modern game.I think a lot of the anti-Hutton comments are the same as the anti-McLeish comments. Some didn't want him here so they're not going to give him a chance.
Quote from: Legion on October 23, 2011, 04:22:07 PMWould much prefer to see Cuellar play there.What does Carlos offer at right back that Hutton doesn't?Carlos can't cross or pass. He doesn't think about what he's doing and as a result either just hoofs it or gets caught in possession.I like Carlos, but as a centre-half. At best he's an average right back. Just like Hutton.
I think a lot of the anti-Hutton comments are the same as the anti-McLeish comments. Some didn't want him here so they're not going to give him a chance.
A question for those who have defended Hutton's challenge on this thread:Would you be willing to pass it off merely as a "strong, hard tackle" if Mulumbu had made it on Gabby, breaking his leg in the process?We are all one eyed from time to time, but I feel that some are defending the indefensible on here.
Quote from: taylorsworkrate on October 23, 2011, 07:30:53 PMA question for those who have defended Hutton's challenge on this thread:Would you be willing to pass it off merely as a "strong, hard tackle" if Mulumbu had made it on Gabby, breaking his leg in the process?We are all one eyed from time to time, but I feel that some are defending the indefensible on here.He didn't break his leg though did he? That's just Hodgson's spin. Football used to be a contact sport.
Quote from: taylorsworkrate on October 23, 2011, 07:30:53 PMA question for those who have defended Hutton's challenge on this thread:Would you be willing to pass it off merely as a "strong, hard tackle" if Mulumbu had made it on Gabby, breaking his leg in the process?We are all one eyed from time to time, but I feel that some are defending the indefensible on here.He didn't break his leg though did he? That's just Hodgson's spin. Football used to be a contact sport.You're very keen to stick up for the Baggies on a couple of threads, is it Bob Taylor's work rate you are celebrating? ;-)
Quote from: Chris Smith on October 23, 2011, 07:46:57 PMQuote from: taylorsworkrate on October 23, 2011, 07:30:53 PMA question for those who have defended Hutton's challenge on this thread:Would you be willing to pass it off merely as a "strong, hard tackle" if Mulumbu had made it on Gabby, breaking his leg in the process?We are all one eyed from time to time, but I feel that some are defending the indefensible on here.He didn't break his leg though did he? That's just Hodgson's spin. Football used to be a contact sport.And it's not anymore.Which is why it deserved a red card.