Heroes & Villains, the Aston Villa fanzine
Heroes & Villains => Heroes Discussion => Topic started by: ozzjim on September 02, 2021, 11:00:28 AM
-
Starting a new thread on this as there are potentially a few affected through the season.
Currently we know the Emis are missing Chelsea, and according to Argentina Everton too. This could have a huge impact this season. Why are Villa being compliant while no one else is?
-
Apparently FIFA are being pushed to penalise clubs who don’t release their players
https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11661/12397060/premier-league-clubs-could-face-possible-fifa-sanctions-after-blocking-players-from-call-ups-to-red-list-countires
We all know that will never happen, don’t we?
(Posted the same in the EMI Martinez thread too)
-
from that sky sports article:
However, FIFA's regulations state that players must be released by their clubs to play for their countries. If they are not, they will be prevented from playing for their clubs during the international window, plus an additional period of five days, unless an exemption is agreed with the relevant national association.
ok, so if you don't release them you lose them for 5 days after the international week.
if you release them, you miss them 10 days (+ travel times) due to quarantine.
not much of a penalty is it!
-
For Martinez and Buendia, there are more international games for Argentina, in October, November, Jan/Feb and March. The covid bands may change of course but it’s not looking very good for them playing much before December.
-
You'd have to also ask the Emis, though, how important is it to them to play for Argentina? It might be a case of losing them for 1, maybe 2 games, but we put ourselves in a good light to them - and any other new signings - that we as a club will fully support their international ambitions.
Hunting for silver linings, it's also good for Jed Steer that he can see that he'll get a decent number of games, even as 2nd choice keeper. Presumably Dean Smith etc have a reasonable amount of faith in him, since we've not brought anyone else in despite knowing Emi^1 will be unavailable (less worried about Emi^2 since his isn't such a specialised position)
-
I’m glad that the Emis will be happy, but players also like to win games, and move up the table and progress in cups. All things that have now been made harder.
-
I do feel proud when we do the right thing but it does leave us behind when every other club acts like shithouses. That's why we have rules rather than goodwill. It was the same with the FA Cup last year, we didn't bitch and moan, we fielded the kids. But we didn't win the Cup either.
Now we are significantly weakened and could be again. Fine if it's a level playing field but this is far from that. The authorities should make the rule and stick to it and that's what we should adhere to.
-
I don't want us to be ruthless and insensitive. I don't want us to ignore our players. I don't want us to have a siege mentality and one that says fuck everyone else.
I want us to do the right thing. I want us not to be club that everyone else thinks are arrogant wankers. I want us to support our players to achieve their aspirations.
I want us to be hard and assertive but fair and appropriate. We're a huge club and we've mostly had a reputation for doing the right thing over the decades. Let's be better. Let's win the right way.
-
Or lose doing the right thing because we are missing 5-6 of our best players, that we pay millions to a year.
I see the argument and I'm paying devil's advocate, but the reality of this is that Fifa and the UK government need to find a solution, and if 20 clubs agree to hold a line, we are not the pushovers that cave in.
-
Agreed. FIFA, UEFA and the Premier League need to sort their shit out.
-
I’m with Oz. The problem isn’t the international breaks, of course players should be released to play for their countries. But the continuing pandemic and the additional rules change that, and so either a solution or compromise is found by the countries, Fifa and the UK/Premier League and they all go, or there isn’t and nobody does.
-
I equate this to the endless accusations thrown at Joe for diving or going down easily, something that is almost an art for the top clubs in this country but suddenly we were in the wrong? I didn't like it but until the same rules apply to all we need to shithouse as much as anyone else.
-
Why Everton? Are Argentina insisting they both play v Bolivia? Need to put our foot down if that is the case given how many clubs have refused to release players for this round.
-
We should be putting a stop to this farce now. We are paying mega wages for players to potentially miss huge chunks of the season with the Covid Rules, this simply isn't acceptable , if the club are happy to do this and let them go and still pay them then bring in some bloody backup options as this is going to leave us very short. Jed Steer was 3rd/4th choice last season and now he's No.1 for a few games absolute lunacy
-
Massive feeling of deja-vu here…..
-
Steer was second choice for the vast majority of last season.
-
Only because Heatons injury. Otherwise he would have been forgotten about.
He's a good keeper and has been professional but I think we all know he isn't high level Premiership standard
-
Its in Argentinas best interests to comply on the agreement we made. If they dont then they wont be released for future games simple.
Compromise is key. Of there is none then thats when you start having club v country row. It was good of villa to let them go although i didnt like it, but Argentina have to show the paying club respect on a agreement made.
-
Only because Heatons injury. Otherwise he would have been forgotten about.
He's a good keeper and has been professional but I think we all know he isn't high level Premiership standard
By people with the memory of a goldfish perhaps.
-
Only because Heatons injury. Otherwise he would have been forgotten about.
He's a good keeper and has been professional but I think we all know he isn't high level Premiership standard
By people with the memory of a goldfish perhaps.
A little harsh on the goldfish there Drummond.
-
Villa have to enforce the original agreement of 2 games only. They were allowed to travel on that basis. Both players were aware of the agreement even though Villa, initially said they couldn't go.
-
Villa have to enforce the original agreement of 2 games only. They were allowed to travel on that basis. Both players were aware of the agreement even though Villa, initially said they couldn't go.
A Villa First policy should be implemented
-
Villa have to enforce the original agreement of 2 games only. They were allowed to travel on that basis. Both players were aware of the agreement even though Villa, initially said they couldn't go.
A Villa First policy should be implemented
Definitely...otherwise sign players that don't play international football...that will work a treat
-
Villa have to enforce the original agreement of 2 games only. They were allowed to travel on that basis. Both players were aware of the agreement even though Villa, initially said they couldn't go.
A Villa First policy should be implemented
Definitely...otherwise sign players that don't play international football...that will work a treat
You miss the point....2 games were agreed. Ok, let them bloody well miss the Everton game!!
-
Emi Buendia didn't even make the bench for Argentina. Royally taking the piss.
-
Emi Buendia didn't even make the bench for Argentina. Royally taking the piss.
Infuriating
Basically paying players to have a Holiday when we have very important tough fixtures coming up.
We need to stop being a soft touch and look after our own interests. We're up against it with Injuries and Covid 19 without the added stress of this nonsense
-
The fault here is with the authorities, there needs to be a consistent policy which applies to all, to maintain a level playing field. Equally we knew these guys were Argentinian internationals when we signed them so were likely to be away , this shouldn't be a surprise.
-
So in conclusion Buendia has gone on a jolly where he's not even going to play, while Nakamba who we could quite happily let go on a 6 month tournament agrees to stay? Only joking Marvelous, fairplay. Catch22 really. You can avoid international players but as soon as they sign for a premiership team they tend to become international players. Maybe if we had a squad of 25 top class players then you get more leverage with them about losing their place. As it is, we have none.
-
For Buendia it's an absolute fucker, basically deprived of any game involvement for a month so that Scaloni can look well 'ard. I'd be pretty fuming were I he.
-
I guess with three games coming up, Argentina named a larger squad to cope with injuries and Buendia missed out on the matchday squad this time.
-
They'll probably not play him again in the next match, then will select him against Bolivia (who are terrible), just to make a point and piss us off.
-
They'll probably not play him again in the next match, then will select him against Bolivia (who are terrible), just to make a point and piss us off.
Yep
-
Given everything that's going on the common sense thing from national teams would be to only call up 23 players, no one benefits from Buendia travelling halfway across the world to do a few training sessions.
-
Was reading that zenit recalled two Brazilian players so they can play vs chelsea. Therefore if they continue to play silly buggers with us recall them before the Argentina game. Start playing ball Argentina
-
I will be very surprised if Buendia returns having not won his first cap. If he DOES return capless, then I think it makes our position much easier to enforce during the next round of games (assuming we still have the red-list restrictions in place)
-
Apparently they might have to go into 2 weeks quarantine in Brazil. Why the fuck we rolled over for our tummy tickles on this one I really don't get.
-
Apparently they might have to go into 2 weeks quarantine in Brazil. Why the fuck we rolled over for our tummy tickles on this one I really don't get.
There is now little doubt we will take a hit in the short term. It will cost us points.
-
Apparently they might have to go into 2 weeks quarantine in Brazil. Why the fuck we rolled over for our tummy tickles on this one I really don't get.
I thought Dougie stayed behind?
-
Apparently they might have to go into 2 weeks quarantine in Brazil. Why the fuck we rolled over for our tummy tickles on this one I really don't get.
I thought Dougie stayed behind?
He did. This is the Emis, they are playing in Brazil.
-
Apparently they might have to go into 2 weeks quarantine in Brazil. Why the fuck we rolled over for our tummy tickles on this one I really don't get.
I thought Dougie stayed behind?
He did. This is the Emis, they are playing in Brazil.
I see, what a bloody nightmare.
-
By the time they're available again, the next international games will be upon us. Complete farce. It is the clubs the players are contracted to and who are paying their wages.
-
It's an absolute disgrace and as said above the time they are due to play again we will have another International Break.
All this for a World Cup that shouldn't be happening.
-
Buendia not even on bench again.
-
Buendia not even on bench again.
Thanks so much there to the arsehole Argentina manager with the name of a dyslexic onion.
-
The Brazilian health authorities want them deported now apparently. Source Tim Vickery.
-
We tried to be friendly and do the right thing given both players are still fairly new to international set up and very important to us (so makes sense not to p*** them off).
Argentina thrown it right back in our faces.
Zero chance we release either for next round of matches imo.
-
We tried to be friendly and do the right thing given both players are still fairly new to international set up and very important to us (so makes sense not to p*** them off).
Argentina thrown it right back in our faces.
Zero chance we release either for next round of matches imo.
Other than threatening them with being dropped, there's not a lot we can do to stop them to be honest. We didn't want them to go this time, but they just went anyway.
-
Talk they are being released after this game tonight.
-
We tried to be friendly and do the right thing given both players are still fairly new to international set up and very important to us (so makes sense not to p*** them off).
Argentina thrown it right back in our faces.
Zero chance we release either for next round of matches imo.
Other than threatening them with being dropped, there's not a lot we can do to stop them to be honest. We didn't want them to go this time, but they just went anyway.
No other prem team other than us and Spurs have Argentine players? Mind you probably the case as I still thought Otamendi was a Man. City player looking at their team tonight and he left Man. City a year ago.
Just annoying likes of Man. United can click their fingers and Cavani gets pulled out of Uruguay squad. Same for Chelsea with Thiago Silva.
Brazil will probably want to call Douglas Luiz for next rounds aswell as probably agreed he could be rested for this given he's been involved all summer.
-
To add to the chaos some health officials just ran onto the pitch and demanding game is called off apparently!
What a waste of time.
-
https://twitter.com/i/broadcasts/1BRJjBmVpWdJw?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1434580187048562690%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=
-
Apparently police on the pitch trying to detain the four players!!
Why on earth weren't they just sent back at the airport?
-
What an absolute shit show. Serves them right, mind.
-
Are our players going to end up in prison, now?
-
Are our players going to end up in prison, now?
They'll be in the Rio jail with the ghost of Ronnie Biggs for sure.
-
Unbelievable scenes, Jeff.
-
The four will be deported. Sooner the better hopefully!
-
How can the Argentinian FA not know the rules? Absolute insanity.
-
Makes me even more grateful that my elder son was able to enter Brazil (Rio de Janeiro) on Wednesday evening!
-
Those "it's only two games, that's a fair compromise" posts have aged well.
-
How can the Argentinian FA not know the rules? Absolute insanity.
Absolutely this (and the Villa), although the FCO Brazil website erroneously still refers to 14 days quarantine, which is no longer required. Their issue is the lack of close relatives in the country.
-
Those "it's only two games, that's a fair compromise" posts have aged well.
Yes, all of us who said that should have known that Villa were lying when they said it was two games and should have studied the Brazilian Covid regulations in detail having assumed that Argentina wouldn't bother to do so.
-
Are our players going to end up in prison, now?
They'll be in the Rio jail with the ghost of Ronnie Biggs for sure.
On the next episode of “Worlds Toughest Prisons” - Rio.
-
Are our players going to end up in prison, now?
Even in handcuffs Martinez would still get into the Arsenal team.
-
Those "it's only two games, that's a fair compromise" posts have aged well.
That's a cheap shot. And to think I rate your posts highly :o
-
Absolute madness and predictable , who on earth do these Footballers think they are and the Argentinians who have made these decisions are a disgrace. Huge mistake letting them go and now probably going to get locked up
-
The match has been suspended due to failure to follow regulations for Argentinian players who came from England.
-
This incident just evidences the arrogance which is endemic generally in professional football. My son is watching the game on television in Rio with his Brasilian family.
-
Sheer stupidity 😂
-
Bunch of ****** all officials, both football and health, from both sides. Vill need to get together with Spurs and fly all 4 out tonight on a private jet.
-
Surely this is on the Argentina FA and FIFA?
-
Brazil v Argentina is wild. Game stopped after 10 mins because a bunch of health officials and cops came on to pitch and, according to commentator, are detaining the 4 PL based Argentina players (Martinez, Buendia, Romero and Lo Celso) for not quarantining.
It seems like it could be Brazilian health officials who were not happy with the four Argentina players who had been in the UK prior to arrival here being allowed to be involved tonight, instead of isolating.
-
Surely this is on the Argentina FA and FIFA?
And the Brazilian authorities who only seemed to realise that Premier League players are likely to have spent some time in the UK three days after they arrived in Brazil.
-
Those "it's only two games, that's a fair compromise" posts have aged well.
That's a cheap shot. And to think I rate your posts highly :o
I meant the posts from the club and others on Twitter to be honest.
-
Put them on that private jet, fly them home, stick them in a Travellodge for 10 days, then tell them in no uncertain terms that the Premier League decision to stop players going wasn't done for shits and giggles, and that next time they think of putting photos of them on their fucking private jet, they can expect to spend so much time in the stiffs that Martinez's time at Arsenal would seem like the highlight of his career.
-
You have to laugh. Ridiculous situation.
-
The real victim is the commentator who’s had to fill half an hour while neymar has a chat.
-
Bunch of ****** all officials, both football and health, from both sides. Vill need to get together with Spurs and fly all 4 out tonight on a private jet.
Could so easily have been stopped by their clubs putting their foot down and ordering them not to go.
Weak management
-
It's even more galling that as far as I can tell, Buendía didn't make the bench in Venezuela nor today, so there was clearly no need for him to have gone in the first place.
-
Bunch of ****** all officials, both football and health, from both sides. Vill need to get together with Spurs and fly all 4 out tonight on a private jet.
Could so easily have been stopped by their clubs putting their foot down and ordering them not to go.
Weak management
It’s not though. If the National side want their players we can’t stand in the way, it’s always been the case. This is on the Argentina FA and FIFA, it should have not got this far.
-
What will happen is they will still play the last 2 games for Argentina and then have to miss 3 games for Villa. Its always us on the losing side.
-
Bunch of ****** all officials, both football and health, from both sides. Vill need to get together with Spurs and fly all 4 out tonight on a private jet.
Could so easily have been stopped by their clubs putting their foot down and ordering them not to go.
Weak management
It’s not though. If the National side want their players we can’t stand in the way, it’s always been the case. This is on the Argentina FA and FIFA, it should have not got this far.
Agree it shouldn’t have gone this far but as far as I’m aware all SA players from prem league were told not to travel. Liverpool didn’t release their Brazilians.
-
Why did it take until 10 minutes into the game for Brazilian health officials to turn up having realised they hadn't followed protocol? Sounds totally staged for effect to me.
-
Bunch of ****** all officials, both football and health, from both sides. Vill need to get together with Spurs and fly all 4 out tonight on a private jet.
Could so easily have been stopped by their clubs putting their foot down and ordering them not to go.
Weak management
It’s not though. If the National side want their players we can’t stand in the way, it’s always been the case. This is on the Argentina FA and FIFA, it should have not got this far.
Agree it shouldn’t have gone this far but as far as I’m aware all SA players from prem league were told not to travel. Liverpool didn’t release their Brazilians.
Was it a case of Liverpool not releasing them or like our Dougie not selected, maybe all staying behind because of the quarantine rule in Brazil?
-
One regular day of Aston Villa. That’s all I ask. Will never happen.
-
Can’t see Brazil not selecting Allison, Fabinho and Firmino.
Edit. In response to Ian
-
Brazil just having a training session now.
-
Can’t see Brazil not selecting Allison, Fabinho and Firmino.
Edit. In response to Ian
Ok, fair enough. But would they have to have gone 14 days before this match to be allowed to play? I’m not arguing by the way, just trying to work out what the hell is really happening here.
-
Looking at the web, you have to quarantine for 14 days if coming from the UK, so I make that any player from this country would have to been there from about the 23rd August.
-
Looking at the web, you have to quarantine for 14 days if coming from the UK, so I make that any player from this country would have to been there from about the 23rd August.
Which begs the question, why were they selected to go? Someone has royally fucked up here.
-
Seems most likely that Argentina knew the rules and just assume they were above them.
-
I must admit, it’s very hard to know what the rules are, but it does seem from what can see it is most definitely a right balls up.
-
Can’t see Brazil not selecting Allison, Fabinho and Firmino.
Edit. In response to Ian
Ok, fair enough. But would they have to have gone 14 days before this match to be allowed to play? I’m not arguing by the way, just trying to work out what the hell is really happening here.
From what I can gather, If the rules were applied equally, yes. Just appears to me that with a few high profile Brazilian absentees and a full strength Argentina they waited for the game to kick off before applying the rules, although if Argentina get awarded the game I can’t see the point. I’m confused, which is easily done!!
-
Absolutely fucking ridiculous.
-
It’s an absolute joke. Our guys could have flown back yesterday really. Bonkers.
-
Can’t see Brazil not selecting Allison, Fabinho and Firmino.
Edit. In response to Ian
Ok, fair enough. But would they have to have gone 14 days before this match to be allowed to play? I’m not arguing by the way, just trying to work out what the hell is really happening here.
From what I can gather, If the rules were applied equally, yes. Just appears to me that with a few high profile Brazilian absentees and a full strength Argentina they waited for the game to kick off before applying the rules, although if Argentina get awarded the game I can’t see the point. I’m confused, which is easily done!!
I think you're right. The rules are Brazil's, not Argentina's. They play at home on Friday too, so none of the Brazilian players from the PL would have been available for that, either.
-
So it’s a scam then from Brazil? This is all been staged by the looks of it and Argentina have walked into a clanger here.
-
-
-
I must admit, it’s very hard to know what the rules are, but it does seem from what can see it is most definitely a right balls up.
"Have you been in any of these countries in the last two weeks?
.
.
.
.
.
.
UK
.
.
.
. "
"Nooooo"
-
You clearly have to be a master of subterfuge to get past Brazilian border staff.
-
Seems like a pretty plausible timeline of what happened
https://mobile.twitter.com/EiFSoccer/status/1434599480473620483
-
How on earth did they think they could get away with lying about being in the UK? I bet loads of Argentinians watched Martinez and Buendia for us against Brentford.
-
No sympathy from me. We told them not to go yet they ignored us and put stupid photos of them on a private jet gloating.
-
Argentinians and Brazilians are having a right ding dong about this on Reddit
-
No sympathy from me. We told them not to go yet they ignored us and put stupid photos of them on a private jet gloating.
Did we tell them not to go?
-
No sympathy from me. We told them not to go yet they ignored us and put stupid photos of them on a private jet gloating.
Did we tell them not to go?
Smith said they did, yes.
-
No sympathy from me. We told them not to go yet they ignored us and put stupid photos of them on a private jet gloating.
Did we tell them not to go?
Yes
Dean Smith revealed he had spoke to both about the situation and made the club’s feelings clear.
He said: “We have sat down with them and told them the Premier League are banning players going to Argentina. So we’ve told them we don’t want them to go out.
“I don’t know what their plans are but they certainly know what our wishes are, that they don’t go, because they’d have to isolate in a government hotel for 10 days when they come back
-
Someone somewhere, the players agents, the Argentina FA, one of our members of staff, someone must have asked the question, what are the guidelines for entering Brazil?
-
If that link Dave posted is correct, and you have one part of the Brazilian government giving them permission to play while another department tries to ban them, it may be that Argentina received permission from someone who was not authorised to grant said authorisation.
-
If that link Dave posted is correct, and you have one part of the Brazilian government giving them permission to play while another department tries to ban them, it may be that Argentina received permission from someone who was not authorised to grant said authorisation.
This seems the most likely explanation. I don't think the 'they lied' part is remotely true either, someone will have advised them that it had been sorted out and handled everything for them.
-
This could really interfere further with our season - what an almighty cock up. If it’s true we told them not to go but they did anyway I can’t imagine it’s not going to create tension once their back.
-
No sympathy from me. We told them not to go yet they ignored us and put stupid photos of them on a private jet gloating.
Did we tell them not to go?
Smith said they did, yes.
Which suggests neither player was particularly frightened of crossing him. Club have got to take a share of the blame here. They should have put their foot down. The likes of Ferguson or Clough would put their foot down
-
They are twats. And the Argentinian football authorities are twats.
It seems these two want to have their cake and eat it.
-
No sympathy from me. We told them not to go yet they ignored us and put stupid photos of them on a private jet gloating.
Did we tell them not to go?
Smith said they did, yes.
Which suggests neither player was particularly frightened of crossing him. Club have got to take a share of the blame here. They should have put their foot down. The likes of Ferguson or Clough would put their foot down
but the FIFA rules are very clear that the club can't refuse to let players go, so the only way we could do that was to threaten them with fines and/or being dropped. Does anyone really want to see the 2 of them dropped from our first team right now? Everyone knows that would be either an empty threat or a clear case of cutting our nose off to spite our face. It's far from ideal but I'd hope that the shit today puts us in a much stronger position for the next window where we can ask them again to drop out to avoid this sort of nonsense.
-
You clearly have to be a master of subterfuge to get past Brazilian border staff.
I've been to Brazil. They'll let anyone in.
-
Someone somewhere, the players agents, the Argentina FA, one of our members of staff, someone must have asked the question, what are the guidelines for entering Brazil?
Fuck that.
Why are any members of our staff accountable?
The players wanted to go, they should fucking well know the rules, and sure as shit the Argentinian football authorities should.
The one group who is not responsible is our club.
-
I think it's fair to say the start of Villa's season has been affected by the odd hiccup.
-
We’ve tried to appease our players whereas other clubs have simply said no and it’s bitten us on the arse even before the events of tonight.
-
Makes my Blood Boil that these elite Footballers and those involved in the game think they are above the laws and rules whilst everyone else is suffering being kept apart from families
-
Daft thing is that Brazil and Argentina are not that far away from qualifying anyway. Argentina have Bolivia, at home, on Thursday so should get 3 points from that with or without Martinez. After what’s happened tonight, the best thing Martinez and Buendia could do is hop on that private jet back to Brum ASAP and forget about the Bolivia match.
-
We had no reason to appease or refuse them this. Like their UK based Brazilian counterparts, they're not allowed into Brazil. Says Brazil.
Maybe the "they'll only play two games" bit actually referred to the other two in this stint, Bolivia and Venezuela, not this one. Although from what I can make of it, they couldn't play in the Bolivia game anyway even if they'd flown to Argentina directly after Venezuela as everybody entering the country must isolate for 7 days. Which surely fecks up almost their entire side.
-
SGT certainly wouldn’t be happy.
-
Apparently Emi Martinez' brother has confirmed Emi and Emi are going to fly to Croatia on Monday and have an arrangement with the Argentine FA to do so.
-
What’s happening in Croatia?
-
If you go to Croatia you don't have to quarantine so they could go there and, at least, exercise and be able to get out of their rooms. They would then be able to come back to the UK after ten days relatively fit to return.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
-
Will we have the same issue with the next international games in October and November? If we do both of the Argentinian players could be missing for a few games again
-
You would sincerely hope this is the last time we allow them to go.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
So your Smith, what exactly would you suggest he have done to prevent this?
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
So your Smith, what exactly would you suggest he have done to prevent this?
Exactly. He told them that he, and the club, didn’t want them to go.
They still went. I mean, we can’t stop injured players leaving now, so I’m not sure what Smith can do about the ones that are fit too.
The days of Ryan Giggs having a toenail injury to miss an international and then making a miraculous recovery for the weekend are gone.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
So your Smith, what exactly would you suggest he have done to prevent this?
60 odd other players didn't travel. So their clubs (I don't think this is Smith decision or influence thing) prevented them from going. We have been soft here.
-
I'm sorry but if playing international fixtures for this ridiculous World Cup means staff are missing large chunks of work,wages should be deducted and donated to Charity.
-
Twitter seems to be full of salty Arsenal fans this morning. Apparently Martinez was a bully in the changing room (eh?!) and keeps mentioning them in interviews since he's left. Very strange bunch, Arsenal fans.
-
Still no plausible suggestion as to what Smith could have done - scapegoat hunting I guess.
Deducting wages means nothing anymore - these players are multimillionaires. Ban them to the reserves - have a word - they are world class players and we need everyone of those right now. Pissing them off isn’t smart in our situation. And suggesting “other” players didn’t go is silly because their FA didn’t ask them too - Brazil as an example didn’t call their European based players. This is specific to Argentina and as far as I’m aware only Villa and Spurs were thus impacted.
I’m pissed off too - it’s a shambles - but let’s not turn this into Smiths fault. Sometimes players just need to take responsibility - hopefully they’ll think twice next time.
-
Smith can ask them not to go and he appears to have done so but he can’t fine them for following FIFA rules.
-
It’s unbelievable that the Smith haters are at it yet again …… I presume it was his fault there were no steak pies against Brentford
People need to get off the guys back and look at all the positive he had done for the club
Villa could not refuse to release the players and FIFA could ban players if they or the club refused them travel
-
The bigger picture here is that the UKs covid situation is worse than other european countries that the Brazilians impose more draconian entry rules on us.
-
The bigger picture here is that the UKs covid situation is worse than other european countries that the Brazilians impose more draconian entry rules on us.
Oh god, why did you have to say that 😂
-
It’s unbelievable that the Smith haters are at it yet again …… I presume it was his fault there were no steak pies against Brentford
People need to get off the guys back and look at all the positive he had done for the club
Villa could not refuse to release the players and FIFA could ban players if they or the club refused them travel
No they can't, players can refuse a call up for any reason they like, so long as FIFA can't prove that it was the clubs decision there's nothing they can do. From the players perspective international football is entirely voluntary, this is why other sports have introduced the idea of central contracts so the players are contracted to be available for international competition even if it means missing club games.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
So your Smith, what exactly would you suggest he have done to prevent this?
What the other managers did in the premier league. Dont allow them to go
-
It’s unbelievable that the Smith haters are at it yet again …… I presume it was his fault there were no steak pies against Brentford
People need to get off the guys back and look at all the positive he had done for the club
Villa could not refuse to release the players and FIFA could ban players if they or the club refused them travel
Its ridiculous anyone who criticises smith now is "smith hater"
-
It’s unbelievable that the Smith haters are at it yet again …… I presume it was his fault there were no steak pies against Brentford
People need to get off the guys back and look at all the positive he had done for the club
Villa could not refuse to release the players and FIFA could ban players if they or the club refused them travel
No they can't, players can refuse a call up for any reason they like, so long as FIFA can't prove that it was the clubs decision there's nothing they can do. From the players perspective international football is entirely voluntary, this is why other sports have introduced the idea of central contracts so the players are contracted to be available for international competition even if it means missing club games.
I'm not sure that's correct Paul. There was that incident with Matip not wanting to play for Cameroon a few years ago, and being banned from playing for Liverpool, despite having already said he didn't want to play for the national team.
-
End of the day it could work out for us in the long term. Sounds like a lot of people and organisations are looking to cover their backs about this monumental feck-up so if the players did lie (and were probably told to) I can see them getting an international ban for a game or too.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
At least he gave Grealish three months off to get rested and well for the Euros and a big summer move ;)
-
Let's face it we weren't going to beat Chelsea anyway.
-
Let's face it we weren't going to beat Chelsea anyway.
Did you think that as well last game of the season too?
-
Isn't our next game away and they wont be resting players for a Euro cup final? A completely different Umboto Gorge.
-
Yep. It's possible we could get a fighting draw out of it with a full team, or even with the reserves out, but the reality is we're probably talking about the difference between losing 2-0 and 3-0.
-
It’s unbelievable that the Smith haters are at it yet again …… I presume it was his fault there were no steak pies against Brentford
People need to get off the guys back and look at all the positive he had done for the club
Villa could not refuse to release the players and FIFA could ban players if they or the club refused them travel
No they can't, players can refuse a call up for any reason they like, so long as FIFA can't prove that it was the clubs decision there's nothing they can do. From the players perspective international football is entirely voluntary, this is why other sports have introduced the idea of central contracts so the players are contracted to be available for international competition even if it means missing club games.
I'm not sure that's correct Paul. There was that incident with Matip not wanting to play for Cameroon a few years ago, and being banned from playing for Liverpool, despite having already said he didn't want to play for the national team.
Yep, agreed, I misread something about it. However I'm not wrong right now because if there is any possibility of a player having to quarantine at any stage they can refuse to join, FIFA changed that last summer.
The bit i misread was about how, right now, national FAs, FIFA and players are all largely following a "gentleman's agreement" process around this because no one wants to be the case that triggers a legal challenge so, in effect, players can withdraw and national teams will rarely raise any objection to it. The article was in Norwegian though (and I mistranslated part of it) because it was specifically about a few of their squad raising moral objections to playing in a world cup in Qatar. A couple of months ago the Norwegian FA voted against boycotting the world cup completely but now the arguments are around whether any of the players will refuse to go (if they qualify of course).
-
Isn't our next game away and they wont be resting players for a Euro cup final? A completely different Umboto Gorge.
Which players did they rest? They hadn't qualified for this season's competition when they came to Villa Park, they were full strength as far as I can recall.
-
Isn't our next game away and they wont be resting players for a Euro cup final? A completely different Umboto Gorge.
Which players did they rest? They hadn't qualified for this season's competition when they came to Villa Park, they were full strength as far as I can recall.
Yep, it was pretty much their best XI, 2-3 players on the bench that were rotation options but none that you'd say were clearly being rested.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
So your Smith, what exactly would you suggest he have done to prevent this?
What the other managers did in the premier league. Dont allow them to go
Fallacy. Only Spurs and Villa had Argentina first XI players called up so he did the same as the other managers. Brazil didn’t call up UK based PL players.
-
You would have thought Argentina will have realised there may be trouble ahead when Brazil didn't call up any of their UK based players.
-
Although they could have done so, as the rules don't apply to Brazilian nationals, hence Willian was allowed to start training at his new club within a couple of days of arriving from Arsenal.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
So your Smith, what exactly would you suggest he have done to prevent this?
What the other managers did in the premier league. Dont allow them to go
Fallacy. Only Spurs and Villa had Argentina first XI players called up so he did the same as the other managers. Brazil didn’t call up UK based PL players.
Other nations did though. Almiron didn't go. Nor did Nakamba for Villa, so it does seem a bit odd.
-
You clearly have to be a master of subterfuge to get past Brazilian border staff.
I've been to Brazil. They'll let anyone in.
I love you providing the evidence so quickly after the point you made.
-
I don't know what's happened here but I blame Dean Smith. None of Bielsa's players were involved.
These are the kind of situations that make me realise how soft smith is. Scared to upset a player so you let them do as they please. Klopp, ferguson, tuchel wouldnt stand for this shit
So your Smith, what exactly would you suggest he have done to prevent this?
What the other managers did in the premier league. Dont allow them to go
Fallacy. Only Spurs and Villa had Argentina first XI players called up so he did the same as the other managers. Brazil didn’t call up UK based PL players.
Other nations did though. Almiron didn't go. Nor did Nakamba for Villa, so it does seem a bit odd.
That's player by player though, Nakamba agreed to not go when he was asked, emi and emi didn't by all accounts (and I can understand why they made the choice they did).
-
I wonder whether the club spoke with their agents, asking them to act as the 'responsible person in the room' for the players?
-
It’s unbelievable that the Smith haters are at it yet again …… I presume it was his fault there were no steak pies against Brentford
People need to get off the guys back and look at all the positive he had done for the club
Villa could not refuse to release the players and FIFA could ban players if they or the club refused them travel
I was joking when I blamed Dean Smith. It might not have been funny, but it was obvious.
-
It’s unbelievable that the Smith haters are at it yet again …… I presume it was his fault there were no steak pies against Brentford
People need to get off the guys back and look at all the positive he had done for the club
Villa could not refuse to release the players and FIFA could ban players if they or the club refused them travel
I was joking when I blamed Dean Smith. It might not have been funny, but it was obvious.
Obviously not funny?
-
A bit.
-
Does anybody know actually what is happening with the Emis and where we're now expecting them back?
-
Does anybody know actually what is happening with the Emis and where we're now expecting them back?
According to AVFC Brasil they're on the way back to Europe. https://twitter.com/AstonVillabrfc/status/1434851004017750016
Original source is an Argentinian paper. https://twitter.com/DiarioOle/status/1434853639844253703
They're not playing against Bolivia and and returning via Madrid.
-
Excellent, so that's the best outcome we could have hoped for? Other than maybe Buendia getting some gametime.
-
Does anybody know actually what is happening with the Emis and where we're now expecting them back?
According to AVFC Brasil they're on the way back to Europe. https://twitter.com/AstonVillabrfc/status/1434851004017750016
Original source is an Argentinian paper. https://twitter.com/DiarioOle/status/1434853639844253703
They're not playing against Bolivia and and returning via Madrid.
More Air miles than Judith Chalmers
-
According to AVFC Brasil they're on the way back to Europe. https://twitter.com/AstonVillabrfc/status/1434851004017750016
Original source is an Argentinian paper. https://twitter.com/DiarioOle/status/1434853639844253703
They're not playing against Bolivia and and returning via Madrid.
More Air miles than Judith Chalmers
The players or me?
-
Does anybody know actually what is happening with the Emis and where we're now expecting them back?
The two Emi's were on the Argentinian team aircraft - Aerolineas Argentinas A330 - which left Sao Paulo at 01.36hrs UK time today and landed in Buenos Aires at 04.22hrs (UK).
They are then taking a scheduled service, being Air Europa to Madrid 787 - which is scheduled to depart Buenos Aires at 16.10hrs (UK) That aircraft is already on the ground so should leave close to time (very few flights around that time). It is an 11+ hour flight which is scheduled to land in Madrid tomorrow morning at 04.10hrs (UK).
The first flight from Madrid to Croatia tomorrow is an Iberia Airlines flight to Dubrovnik, A320, leaving at 06.45hrs (UK), which is scheduled to land at 09.35hrs (UK).
If they are then isolating for 10 days then they're only going to land back in the UK just in advance of the Everton home game!
-
Eeeeaaastie?
-
Does anybody know actually what is happening with the Emis and where we're now expecting them back?
The two Emi's were on the Argentinian team aircraft - Aerolineas Argentinas A330 - which left Sao Paulo at 01.36hrs UK time today and landed in Buenos Aires at 04.22hrs (UK).
They are then taking a scheduled service, being Air Europa to Madrid 787 - which is scheduled to depart Buenos Aires at 16.10hrs (UK) That aircraft is already on the ground so should leave close to time (very few flights around that time). It is an 11+ hour flight which is scheduled to land in Madrid tomorrow morning at 04.10hrs (UK).
The first flight from Madrid to Croatia tomorrow is an Iberia Airlines flight to Dubrovnik, A320, leaving at 06.45hrs (UK), which is scheduled to land at 09.35hrs (UK).
If they are then isolating for 10 days then they're only going to land back in the UK just in advance of the Everton home game!
Good info. I thought that they'd get into Croatia tomorrow, which means they can't fly back into the UK until the day of the Everton game.
-
Does anybody know actually what is happening with the Emis and where we're now expecting them back?
The two Emi's were on the Argentinian team aircraft - Aerolineas Argentinas A330 - which left Sao Paulo at 01.36hrs UK time today and landed in Buenos Aires at 04.22hrs (UK).
They are then taking a scheduled service, being Air Europa to Madrid 787 - which is scheduled to depart Buenos Aires at 16.10hrs (UK) That aircraft is already on the ground so should leave close to time (very few flights around that time). It is an 11+ hour flight which is scheduled to land in Madrid tomorrow morning at 04.10hrs (UK).
The first flight from Madrid to Croatia tomorrow is an Iberia Airlines flight to Dubrovnik, A320, leaving at 06.45hrs (UK), which is scheduled to land at 09.35hrs (UK).
If they are then isolating for 10 days then they're only going to land back in the UK just in advance of the Everton home game!
Good info. I thought that they'd get into Croatia tomorrow, which means they can't fly back into the UK until the day of the Everton game.
When does the 10 day counting start? Surely from leaving Argentina rather than arrival in Croatia?
-
It's full days in quarantine, not periods of 24 hours since escaping from wherever. And I assume the count will start Wednesday as day 1. Day 10 will be Friday, free to fly back Saturday.
-
From what I’ve read, it seemed pretty pointless in Buendia going at all. I’m still really annoyed that our players were jetted out without knowing if the match in Brazil would go ahead. What a waste of everyone’s time. Let’s hope the arrangements are in place correctly for the next set of matches. If there’s any blame to be apportioned, it lays squarely with the players.
-
The whole thing is utterly ludicrous. You have fans in packed stadiums hugging and celebrating with one another having interacted with vaccinated and unvaccinated people all around them before coming to games. Players as much as they want to be careful, and I realize that can vary, they are human too and live lives outside of sport. And yet despite that there are these rules in place that are different from country to country, region to region that require quarantine rules and isolation periods. I’m all for safety, and vaccines, and doing all we can to get through this but the inconsistencies are what piss people off the most.
-
Lionel Messi could probably refuse a game or two for Argentina, should the situation require it. Safe in the knowledge he'll be back in the team later.
Martinez and Buendia are still building their reputation with the national side. Neither would be guaranteed first picks at this stage (though Martinez must be close to that now). So they can't really say no when their country asks - especially when one of those games is against the old enemy.
The scenes yesterday were pure theatre - and humiliating for Argentina. So it's either a monumental phuck up by someone at the AFA. Or -as someone mentioned earlier on this thread - deiberate mixed messages from the Brazilian authorities to leave them in the shit.
If the knock on effect is Brazil end up playing a weakened Argentina = even better for them.
-
Tim Vickery trying to explain everything on SSN with Mr Cool’s Dream, Ian Mum’s definitive Style Council history, on the shelf behind him. I knew he was a clever bloke with impeccable taste.
As you were.
-
If both players are vaccinated then I'm struggling to see what the issue is with them returning to play for us. The Brazil police stunt was just that, utterly shameless.
-
If both players are vaccinated then I'm struggling to see what the issue is with them returning to play for us
You not been following the news for the last 18 months ?
-
Matt Law has tweeted that Martinez has said that Villa did not know the quarantine rules for Brazil.....
-
Tim Vickery trying to explain everything on SSN with Mr Cool’s Dream, Ian Mum’s definitive Style Council history, on the shelf behind him. I knew he was a clever bloke with impeccable taste.
As you were.
If that was the same interview of which I just caught part, he wasn’t sure that the Emis had left Argentina
-
Matt Law has tweeted that Martinez has said that Villa did not know the quarantine rules for Brazil.....
I mean martinez is making the club look like fools if he said that
-
Matt Law has tweeted that Martinez has said that Villa did not know the quarantine rules for Brazil.....
I mean martinez is making the club look like fools if he said that
Why?
Why do we need to know the rules about Brazil?
-
Do any of us know the rules? Stay at home but it's ok go out to work, wear a mask but not in a work place. We have only 50% allowed to come into work but they can all go out to a nightclub together. It's all so very made up.
-
Matt Law has tweeted that Martinez has said that Villa did not know the quarantine rules for Brazil.....
I mean martinez is making the club look like fools if he said that
I’d say everyone involved this has looked like fools, except Villa. Smith advised them not to go but they went.
-
Matt Law has tweeted that Martinez has said that Villa did not know the quarantine rules for Brazil.....
I mean martinez is making the club look like fools if he said that
He's making the AFA and FIFA look fools. Surely it's up to them to make players aware of the rules. You'd hope the player himself would make the effort to check as well.
-
Matt Law has tweeted that Martinez has said that Villa did not know the quarantine rules for Brazil.....
I mean martinez is making the club look like fools if he said that
He's making the AFA and FIFA look fools. Surely it's up to them to make players aware of the rules. You'd hope the player himself would make the effort to check as well.
In most cases, I’d agree. But how many ex players struggle because everything gets done for them during their playing days. All they do is bring some hand luggage, the rest is taken care of for them. They barely have to think.
-
Matt Law has tweeted that Martinez has said that Villa did not know the quarantine rules for Brazil.....
I mean martinez is making the club look like fools if he said that
Why?
Why do we need to know the rules about Brazil?
Especially as he was there not that long ago playing in Copa America.
-
Seems like the club statement from 8 days ago was spot on despite the naysayers.
-
Yep I think so too BV.
-
This is all a bit of a fiasco but the club played it pretty well, all things considered.
-
If both players are vaccinated then I'm struggling to see what the issue is with them returning to play for us
You not been following the news for the last 18 months ?
Vaccines aren't out 18 months...
-
If Martinez is trying to deflect by saying villla didn’t know about the rules for Brazil, then frankly he is being a twat.
HE wanted to go, against club wishes.
HE has the ability to think for himself and understand all the implications of travel (hmmmm, maybe that’s taking it a little far, expecting a professional footballer to be able to think for themselves).
HE ‘lied’ to the authorities about his origins of travel.
He needs to take some fucking personal responsibility because it looks to me like he’s becoming a bit of an ‘entitled’ prick.
-
What a load a hysterical shite. He wanted to play for his country in the biggest derby in international football, and assumed, as anyone in his position would, that the people who are paid to know the rules regarding travel and Covid and so on wouldn't be amateurish idiots.
-
What a load a hysterical shite. He wanted to play for his country in the biggest derby in international football, and assumed, as anyone in his position would, that the people who are paid to know the rules regarding travel and Covid and so on wouldn't be amateurish idiots.
Completely agree. Brazil made a fucking pigs ear of this also which happened to be against their fiercest rivals. I don’t see why the four players are being singled out like they went out of their way to con the system. It’s not like they took a secret covert flight out there. It was all quite public
-
Are the two Emi's definitely still out of the Chelsea clash even if they come back from a green country? If so, what's the point of going to Croatia?
-
Yes. The point of going to Croatia is that they don't have to isolate in a bog standard hotel room while they're there, as they would if they went straight from South America to the UK, so can keep themselves active and fit, hopefully.
-
Yes. The point of going to Croatia is that they don't have to isolate in a bog standard hotel room while they're there, as they would if they went straight from South America to the UK, so can keep themselves active and fit, hopefully.
Righto, thanks mate. I presume they also miss the Everton game, unless they arrive back tomorrow?
-
There appears to be some debate but greater minds than mine seem to have deduced that they'll likely be back the day of the Everton game so it would be unlikely they'd play.
-
It's a bugger's muddle.
-
Tim Vickery on 5 live:
Apparently, all the Argentinian premier league players were told on the Saturday by the Brazilian authorities that they had to quarantine but the team decided to travel to the game on Sunday anyway. The Argentina association thought (even after this notification on Saturday) that the same rules as those in place during the Copa America during Brazil still applied.
5 Live also said that Villa did give permission for our players to go but Tottenham didn’t and they decided to travel anyway.
Martinez is quoted as saying that “After winning the Copa America, the whole team wants to be with the group. It’s something beautiful that we have and we assume the consequences.”
-
You clearly have to be a master of subterfuge to get past Brazilian border staff.
I've been to Brazil. They'll let anyone in.
Getting into Brasil is easy, it's leaving that's the difficult part. ;)
-
Tim Vickery trying to explain everything on SSN with Mr Cool’s Dream, Ian Mum’s definitive Style Council history, on the shelf behind him. I knew he was a clever bloke with impeccable taste.
As you were.
Ian what? There's a surname called "Mum"?! Well, I'll be damned...
-
Looks like the Brazilian no shows will be impacted too. Now it is Liverpool, Man C, Chelsea etc watch it all kick off.
-
Thiago Silva out of Villa game. Brazil have banned all the players who refused to go with the exception of Richarlison as thanks for releasing him for the Olympics when they didn't have to.
-
Tim Vickery trying to explain everything on SSN with Mr Cool’s Dream, Ian Mum’s definitive Style Council history, on the shelf behind him. I knew he was a clever bloke with impeccable taste.
As you were.
Ian what? There's a surname called "Mum"?! Well, I'll be damned...
Sorry, Munn. Autocorrect compounded by my terrible eyesight.
-
Thiago Silva out of Villa game. Brazil have banned all the players who refused to go with the exception of Richarlison as thanks for releasing him for the Olympics when they didn't have to.
Although it helps us thats very bitter by the Brazilians.
-
It’s not. A rule has to be implemented and respected.
-
Simon Jordan mentioned any Brasil players called up from England would have to isolate for ten days anyway, so what's the point of going
-
Tim Vickery trying to explain everything on SSN with Mr Cool’s Dream, Ian Mum’s definitive Style Council history, on the shelf behind him. I knew he was a clever bloke with impeccable taste.
As you were.
Ian what? There's a surname called "Mum"?! Well, I'll be damned...
Sorry, Munn. Autocorrect compounded by my terrible eyesight.
Ha...bit of a shame, it was a great quirk.
-
Simon Jordan mentioned any Brasil players called up from England would have to isolate for ten days anyway, so what's the point of going
He's wrong. Brazilian nationals are exempt from that rule. Hence Willian started training with his new club more or less as soon as he arrived from Arsenal.
-
Simon Jordan mentioned any Brasil players called up from England would have to isolate for ten days anyway, so what's the point of going
He's wrong. Brazilian nationals are exempt from that rule. Hence Willian started training with his new club more or less as soon as he arrived from Arsenal.
Correct.
-
Smith officially said Buendia and Martinez
"They are over in Croatia. We spoke with the authorities to make sure it was the right thing to do. They’re training over there, working hard to get ready for Everton next week."
-
I see that both Brazil and Argentina both won their games comfortably, even without our contingent.
-
Thiago Silva out of Villa game. Brazil have banned all the players who refused to go with the exception of Richarlison as thanks for releasing him for the Olympics when they didn't have to.
Although it helps us thats very bitter by the Brazilians.
Don't think he's played for Chelsea yet this season, so he's probably not someone they're really relying on.
-
Thiago Silva out of Villa game. Brazil have banned all the players who refused to go with the exception of Richarlison as thanks for releasing him for the Olympics when they didn't have to.
Although it helps us thats very bitter by the Brazilians.
Don't think he's played for Chelsea yet this season, so he's probably not someone they're really relying on.
Apparently no one will miss any games today now, apart from our two of course.
-
And Tottenham. Still bollocks though, isn't it?
-
Definite bollocks that FIFA decided to override their own rules after the fact.
I saw a mention that more countries were being added to the UK Red list the other day. I'm half expecting Croatia to be one of them.
-
I see that both Brazil and Argentina both won their games comfortably, even without our contingent.
What are you....trying to say...?
-
Haven't seen this mentioned but our boys were training with Hajduk Split while in Croatia so maybe it was all a bit better planned out than we have given the club credit for.
-
Plans to resolve football’s club-versus-country crisis were branded the “worst possible solution” on Wednesday night after the Government refused to halve the time spent in coronavirus quarantine by players returning from red-list countries.
Ministers on Wednesday agreed to relax travel restrictions for next month’s World Cup qualifiers by allowing those involved to avoid isolating for 10 days in a designated hotel upon their return.
But it was made clear players would still have to spend a full week and a half in supervised quarantine and would only be allowed outside to train and play.
The Premier League had put forward a plan to Government that would have seen affected players spend five days in club bubbles where their Covid status could be checked.
But that was rejected by ministers, who were also planning to exclude those not fully vaccinated against Covid-19 from any easing of the rules.
A source at one of the worst affected clubs told Telegraph Sport: “This so-called solution is ridiculous. The clubs involved in the process think anything longer than five days is no solution at all – it’s as unreasonable as it is unworkable.
“The Premier League has clearly been unable to exert any meaningful influence on this discussion.”
Under the Government plan, eligible players would spend 10 days quarantining in a secured private residence or hotel – with 24-hour security.
They would be permitted no guests or visitors other than Public Health England, with meals to be dropped at the door, and would be required to use private, individual transport going to and from training and games.
“To be honest, this feels like the worst possible solution,” the club source added. “A ‘solution’ in name only. More accurately, an unworkable, impractical mess.”
A failure to strike a deal over the red-list row could witness a repeat of clubs’ refusal this month to release players for international duty.
That had seen them face being banned by Fifa from fielding those players, a threat that only subsided after the Government agreed to consider relaxing red-list rules.
Even a halving of the quarantine period for players returning from affected countries would not prevent many missing their clubs’ next match after the upcoming international break.
Brazil, Argentina and other countries in the Americas play three matches in that period, the last of which kick-off in the early hours of the morning of Friday October 15 UK time.
That would deprive many Premier League clubs of some of their best players when they return to action the following afternoon.
The same club source said talks to avoid this could not begin until the quarantine issue was resolved
-
The government and football authorities have agreed a deal that will allow full vaccinated players to travel to red list countries for international duty without having to quarantine on their return to the UK.
This will be subject to a code of conduct which includes restrictions on transport, close contact, and stringent protocols on testing, vaccination and bubbles.
A government spokesperson said: "We have worked closely with football authorities to achieve an outcome that balances the interests of both club and country while maintaining the highest levels of public health and safety.
"Our best defence against the virus is vaccination and these new measures will allow fully vaccinated players to fulfill their international duties in the safest, most practical way possible, while allowing them to train and play with their clubs as early as possible upon their return."
-
I guess now we'll find out who's been vaccinated and who hasn't.
-
Looks like our guys have been double jabbed then.
Ashley Preece
@PreeceObserver
Dean Smith confirmed via Sky Sports that those travelling to red-list countries - Martinez, Nakamba & Traore - have been double-jabbed. Govt now confirm double-jabbed players can fulfil international matches, with Martinez, Nakamba & Traore all OK to return for #avfc vs Wolves
-
Good news!
-
That's great news.
-
There are 5 england players who have refused the vaccination
Three senior team members have reportedly insisted that they are too healthy to suffer Covid, a decision that potentially endangers England's World Cup hopes in Qatar next year where organisers plan to ban unvaccinated players.
At least two others are said to have refused the jabs, with some thought to have swallowed conspiracy theories and online 'misinformation' while others have apparently been pressured by their wives.
Southgate:
We will have an idea because there is going to be some things where one group is going to go through one door and another will go through another over the next few months, so I don’t know quite how we are going to keep that medical confidentiality.
-
Tammy Abraham said: “It is a personal choice. People are entitled to do what they want to do with their bodies. For me, it was a different situation. I am vaccinated. That is a personal choice.”
“It’s a personal thing for me. I have contracted the virus before, I am in Italy and, for me, it is the right thing to do. Everyone is entitled to do what they want and what is personal to them. They should make the decision about what they want to do.”
-
Tammy Abraham said: “It is a personal choice. People are entitled to do what they want to do with their bodies. For me, it was a different situation. I am vaccinated. That is a personal choice.”
“It’s a personal thing for me. I have contracted the virus before, I am in Italy and, for me, it is the right thing to do. Everyone is entitled to do what they want and what is personal to them. They should make the decision about what they want to do.”
Tammy “aleister Crowley do what thou wilt” Abraham. Footballers aren’t the brightest sparks are they? Sometimes it’s best to say nothing
-
Dougie called up for Brazil