Heroes & Villains, the Aston Villa fanzine
Heroes & Villains => Heroes Discussion => Topic started by: dave.woodhall on January 05, 2020, 03:12:55 PM
-
www.thebirminghampress.com
Read it and weep.
-
Duly wept.
-
I used to rage against the way the FA Cup was going but I can't find the anger anymore. Perhaps it's my age, cynicism or a combination of both but I've all but given up. Our owners will value staying in the PL above the cup and from a financial point of view I can't really argue. I do hope we give it a go on Wednesday though, anything else will increase my cynicism 10 fold.
-
Half a dozen players, properly coached (I know…) and our future would be a lot more promising
It's something we can dream of, as is winning the trophy. To those of us that still see it as the Holy Grail I'm prepared to wait until we have a team that not only reach the final but actually win it which is partly why I wasn't bothered by the result yesterday. Probably the first time ever for a FA Cup game. That and I'm still shellshocked from 2015.
-
I'm with you, Nev. The F.A. had arguably the greatest football competition in the world, with a history, traditions and values ingrained into the nations's psyche. It then preceded to kill it through first its complicity in creating the money monster that is the Premier League and then a further thousand other cuts at the behest of the bigger clubs for whom a tricky tie at Tranmere or a second replay at neutral Nottingham is too much bother.
-
For a certain generation of fans, it's the final piece in the jigsaw. The one that completes the collection.
When we were growing up it was the pre-eminent cup competition, and nothing else compared for romance, history, tradition and glory
Would I take winning the FA Cup and relegation in the same season?
In a heartbeat.
Others may think differently.
-
For a certain generation of fans, it's the final piece in the jigsaw. The one that completes the collection.
When we were growing up it was the pre-eminent cup competition, and nothing else compared for romance, history, tradition and glory
Would I take winning the FA Cup and relegation in the same season?
In a heartbeat.
Others may think differently.
So would I. But realistically, except in exceptional circumstances, if you aren't good enough nowadays to be at least mid-table in the Premier League you won't be good enough to win the cup.
-
Summed up my feelings about Villa and the FA Cup perfectly.
-
4-4-3 and we still lost :)
-
On the council estate I grew up on, there was not a person out on FA Cup Final day, irrespective of who was playing. I can reluctantly accept that relegation would be so catastrophic to the club that we have to prioritise, but why teams that are safe don't give it respect is beyond me.
-
On the council estate I grew up on, there was not a person out on FA Cup Final day, irrespective of who was playing. I can reluctantly accept that relegation would be so catastrophic to the club that we have to prioritise, but why teams that are safe don't give it respect is beyond me.
Yes I remember back in the day watching from about 12pm. With tv cameras on the coaches , celeb fans on Saint and greavsey flicking from bbc to itv and back . Actually walking to the tv and turning over the box
-
Kids, if you want a flavour of what the Cup once was, get on that there YouTube and look up "Meanwhile Back In Sunderland". Filmed around the town on the day of the 1973 final, in terms of social history and an understanding of how football in general and the F.A. Cup in particular could galvanize and unite a community, I think it's one of the greatest football-related documentaries of all time.
-
On the council estate I grew up on, there was not a person out on FA Cup Final day, irrespective of who was playing. I can reluctantly accept that relegation would be so catastrophic to the club that we have to prioritise, but why teams that are safe don't give it respect is beyond me.
This is what I don't understand. There are teams who haven't won a trophy in decades, won't go down or finish in the top four, yet they still put their reserves out in the FA CUp.
-
On the council estate I grew up on, there was not a person out on FA Cup Final day, irrespective of who was playing. I can reluctantly accept that relegation would be so catastrophic to the club that we have to prioritise, but why teams that are safe don't give it respect is beyond me.
Yes I remember back in the day watching from about 12pm. With tv cameras on the coaches , celeb fans on Saint and greavsey flicking from bbc to itv and back . Actually walking to the tv and turning over the box
Don't forget It's a Cup Final Knockout.
-
FA Cup final day was massive back when I was a kid, although that's probably in part due to it being a rare chance to watch a live game on telly.
It's weird to think that there's now a generation that would find it hard to believe that FA Cup games were once massive, pretty much regardless of who the away team were the cup games were nearly always well above the league average attendances.
-
FA Cup final day was massive back when I was a kid, although that's probably in part due to it being a rare chance to watch a live game on telly.
It's weird to think that there's now a generation that would find it hard to believe that FA Cup games were once massive, pretty much regardless of who the away team were the cup games were nearly always well above the league average attendances.
Like when we got 43,000 for a cup replay against a team from division three and a month later 15,000 for a league game.
-
The first FA Cup games I saw at Villa Park were 1967/68, both against sides in our division.
R3 Millwall ( 34,703 in the cup, 14,886 in the league )
R4 Rotherham (33,442 in the cup, 13,673 in the league )
-
Great read Dave I also love FA Cup third round day it's a shame that the Premier League and Champions League is all everybody cares about apart from Wigan who won it I bet they wouldn't swop that win over Man City for Premier League status.
-
On the council estate I grew up on, there was not a person out on FA Cup Final day, irrespective of who was playing. I can reluctantly accept that relegation would be so catastrophic to the club that we have to prioritise, but why teams that are safe don't give it respect is beyond me.
This is what I don't understand. There are teams who haven't won a trophy in decades, won't go down or finish in the top four, yet they still put their reserves out in the FA CUp.
This is where I am. I am probably a bit less misty eyed about the FA cup than some. I'd love to win it but am hard nosed enough to realise the medium term future of the club would be better served by avoiding relegation. But for established PL clubs with deeper squads and in no danger, I can't understand why they aren't busting a gut to win a pot. Fair play to Wolves who are fighting on all fronts with a small squad, but still put out a strong team.
-
4-4-3 and we still lost :)
To be fair, we always struggle with the extra man!
-
Relegation or FA cup win?
FA cup everyday
Maybe that's selfish as one of the older fans we have seen the lot but that is the holy grail to me.
We should be grateful that at least we made the final twice in the last 20 years (albeit abject surrender when we did) there are teams that have never had a sniff in their entire lifetime.
When the FA sanctioned the biggest club at the time to skip a year from their own top trophy for promotional and financial gains then you knew the cup was doomed. The only way back is for it to be seeded and weighted in favour of the bigger teams as the thought of leaving the draw to chance (the thing that make the cup for me) is abhorrent to them in case they draw another Prem team
-
Relegation or FA cup win?
It's a toughie. Having thought about it, though, I reckon I would rather win the FA Cup than get relegated.
-
I think our chances of winning the FA Cup are better if we stay in the Premier League. Given that the odds are against us having the squad to do it this year then I would argue that trying to make sure we stay up gives more chance of doing it at some point in the future.
-
I think our chances of winning the FA Cup are better if we stay in the Premier League. Given that the odds are against us having the squad to do it this year then I would argue that trying to make sure we stay up gives more chance of doing it at some point in the future.
Exactly. Given the money in modern football and FFP, relegation is a disaster. Stay up, consolidate, retain some of our best players and then we can fight on all fronts.
-
I think our chances of winning the FA Cup are better if we stay in the Premier League. Given that the odds are against us having the squad to do it this year then I would argue that trying to make sure we stay up gives more chance of doing it at some point in the future.
Exactly. Given the money in modern football and FFP, relegation is a disaster. Stay up, consolidate, retain some of our best players and then we can fight on all fronts.
This and I can remember us winning it in 57 ! We have to do all possible to avoid relegation that would lead to us losing all of our best players.
-
I'd much rather stay in the Premier League than win the FA Cup
-
Does anyone remember when we played Watford at Villa park in 83 (I think). There was well over 40,000. Pretty sure it was 3rd round. The FA cup back then was pure magic. Shame what's happened to it now, but I agree for now with some of the other posters that our best chance of actually winning the cup is to avoid relegation and kick on from there.
-
It was the Fifth Round. A photo from the match was on the Subbuteo set I had as a youth.
Here... (https://www.google.com/search?q=subbuteo+set+villa+watford&client=ms-android-samsung-ss&prmd=sinv&sxsrf=ACYBGNRdRvlJgACjLBAe3RWOROlJNZi2_Q:1578324875211&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjAu5uspu_mAhW_URUIHREQAecQ_AUoAnoECA0QAg&biw=360&bih=620#imgrc=SgEjVlMBvPiHrM)
I always thought the image was of them scoring, but they're actually putting it just wide as shown from about four minutes in on the video below (from the Barnes free kick).
Highlights of the match...
-
www.thebirminghampress.com
Read it and weep.
I can't be arsed. ;)
I agree with it Mr W. It's so frustrating, that what was the greatest cup competition of them all is reduced to what we see now. Clubs can't be arsed, so the fans can't be. So the TV companies can't be, so the clubs can't be. Which just means the spiral continues until they don't bother with it any more.
I refuse to watch any of it now we're out. I just hope all the remaining 'big clubs' get drawn against each other repeatedly and let other clubs have some fun.
-
Bollocks to the FA Cup - I can't wait for us to survive this season so that I can have "17th in the league, 2019/20" tattooed across my tits.
-
Bollocks to the FA Cup - I can't wait for us to survive this season so that I can have "17th in the league, 2019/20" tattooed across my tits.
Dirty Glory Hunter.
-
Another perfect summing up of proceedings and the situation, Mr Woodhall!
I wept on Saturday going home on the tube, and have no tears left!!!
-
And 53,000 turning up to VP on a school night (including a 14 year-old me) to see Forest play Swindon in a 5th round second replay in '67.
-
I reminded myself of what it used to be by looking back at the 57 final and that spectacular first goal of Peter Mac, I was a thirteen year old watching my idols on the tele and could not believe the size of the crowd and wished I could have been there. Sad to say it means so little these days we should let it die gracefully as for me if we were to be relegated I may not be around to see Villa get promoted again.
-
Relegation or FA cup win?
It's a toughie. Having thought about it, though, I reckon I would rather win the FA Cup than get relegated.
Actually, relegation or fa cup win is not a difficult choice at all. Staying up or fa cup win? Now that's a toughie ;)
-
I understand why people lament the demise of the FA Cup. It really was a massive deal in my childhood. Cup Final day was a big thing everywhere despite who was playing. As others have said, a lot of that was down to the fact that it was pretty much the only live domestic game you saw on the telly back then. That said, Villa need to stay up this season or face a very uncertain future. Let's stay up, build again and then go for it.
-
Kids, if you want a flavour of what the Cup once was, get on that there YouTube and look up "Meanwhile Back In Sunderland". Filmed around the town on the day of the 1973 final, in terms of social history and an understanding of how football in general and the F.A. Cup in particular could galvanize and unite a community, I think it's one of the greatest football-related documentaries of all time.
Wow that’s must see footage in 4 parts (on YouTube). I can remember the FA cup final being like this in the 70s & 80s although sadly not with Villa involved at the time.
-
It was the Fifth Round. A photo from the match was on the Subbuteo set I had as a youth.
Here... (https://www.google.com/search?q=subbuteo+set+villa+watford&client=ms-android-samsung-ss&prmd=sinv&sxsrf=ACYBGNRdRvlJgACjLBAe3RWOROlJNZi2_Q:1578324875211&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjAu5uspu_mAhW_URUIHREQAecQ_AUoAnoECA0QAg&biw=360&bih=620#imgrc=SgEjVlMBvPiHrM)
I always thought the image was of them scoring, but they're actually putting it just wide as shown from about four minutes in on the video below (from the Barnes free kick).
Highlights of the match...
Watford warm up in front of the Holte?! I don’t remember the away teams doing that, was that a one off or a regular thing?