The main point is, which perhaps PL hasn't grasped, is that most teams play slightly different away from home to the way they play at home. The away team is usually set up to play a more defensive style and it is then the job of the home team to counter this and find a way of attacking them successfully so that they score a goal. If the home team succeeds in scoring a goal then the away team has to change its tactics to enable it to score an equaliser.So, to say we play exactly the same at home as we do away, is IMO very naive and if it is 100 per cent correct, shows a very poor set of tactics.
The Guardian summed it up pretty well in their "FA Cup third round: 10 talking points from this weekend's action"1) Villa's appalling home record continuesThere were plenty of empty seats inside Villa Park on Saturday but it is more remarkable how many home supporters continue to turn up. Villa's record at home over the last two and a-half years has been nothing short of appalling, which is why the 2-1 defeat by League One Sheffield United in the FA Cup was not the shock some might consider it to be. Villa have won only 11 of 48 Premier League home games going back to the start of the 2011-12 season, when Alex McLeish was in charge. Of the 15 teams that have been in the top flight throughout that period, Villa have scored the fewest number of goals and they are the only club to fail to average a point per game in front of their own supporters. Broaden the sample to include all 26 clubs that have featured in the Premier League since 2011-12 and only Wolverhampton Wanderers and Bolton Wanderers, both of whom were relegated, averaged fewer points at home. Villa, in short, are escaping the bottom three purely as a result of their away form, which, in fairness, is remarkably good – they have picked up more points on their travels this season than second-placed Manchester City and as many as third-placed Chelsea. It is not, however, much fun if you are a regular visitor to Villa Park, where victories and entertainment are in short supply. Humiliating cup defeats against lower-league opposition merely compound the misery.