I am with Percy on this one - he saved far more goals than he conceded due to clangers. When they were still speaking to each other, Gregory said that James made a few mistakes because he was a decisive keeper and was brave enough to venture off his line. Other keepers would stay on the line, be beaten by a header and blame their defence, getting off scot free themselves.
Re THAT game, my memory is of him making a few good saves as the tide started to turn against us in the 2nd half before they scored. Not for a moment did I blame him for the goal as I felt he was keeping us in it, and their goal was cominig for a while. . And I have absolutely no intention of watching the dvd of that game to see if my memory is correct.