50% Villa Craig Gardner

[eastie]

I'd much rather Bannan play... Or even someone like Guthrie.

Saying that, if we're gonna take a reserve centre mid from Newcastle I'd prefer Gosling!

Guthrie maybe, but bannan -no!
Barry bannan will never be good enough at this level, championship player at best .

[N'Zimidy]

Guthrie is far, far better than Gosling FYI.

Bannan in a 5 man midfield actually playing in the centre is one of our best players. He'll make it under a good manager that knows how teams are actually meant to pass the ball rather than kick and run.

[1_Pablo_Angel]

Bannan is one of our only technically sound players. Will be a good player at the very least in a side that actually plays football.

[eastie]

Gardner, Clark and herd will all be better players for villa than bannan in my opinion.

[myf]

Bannan didn't really impress under gh either and he was all for passing football. I've been really disappointed with Bannan this year