My theory is this. Up until the last two seasons he (McLeish) has always done a decent, if dull, job. Even when he managed third place at Rangers it wasn't entirely his fault as he was doing so in a context of a small budget and at a time Hearts were spending big.Following that ninth place finish, McLeish brought in Peter 'Jonah' Grant as his assistant following the departure of Roy Aitken. Wherever he's been Grant has brought nothing but bad luck and underacheivement to clubs. Here, this is probably exacerbated by McLeish losing his long term sidekick Andy Watson and putting even more trust in Grant. McLeish has had two bad seasons which just so happen to coincide with his working with Grant. Grant was part of the disastorous Mowbray reign at Celtic, was assistant at relegated West Brom and had a poor time as manager of Norwich.
I've not seen the stats of Peter Grants managerial record compiled in one place before but I've always had the impression it wasn't great. So because I'm bored I decided to have a delve...I have omitted anything before 2006 as exact dates etc are too time consuming to research.Oct 2006 - Oct 2007. Norwich managerW 18 D 12 L24. Grant was sacked 10 games into new season while Nowich were in relegating zone.Jul 08- Jun 09. West Brom first team coachW 8 D 8. L 22. WBA relegated in bottom place.June 09 - Mar 10. Celtic first team coachW 17. D 6. L 7. Mowbray and Grant sacked after losing 4-0 to the mighty St Mirren.Jul 10 - Jul 11. Noses first team coachW 8. D 15 L15. Relegated in 18th placeTo present at Villa. W 7 D 14. L 12And maybe it's worth pointing out that AM's previous season at Blues with Roy Aitken they finished 9th with a record of W13. D11. L14.IN SUMMARY : Peter Grant is a total TWAT. (You only have to sit behind the Dugout & watch him to know that.)
IN SUMMARY : Peter Grant is a total TWAT. (You only have to sit behind the Dugout & watch him to know that.)
I've always thought Peter Grant has had that hunted "I don't really know what I'm doing; do you think anyone has noticed yet? " look. But, what role has KMac played in the coaching this season? Is he now "soiled goods"?Just who is calling the shots in terms of tactics, playing style, etc? - I suppose McL is in overall terms but how much is influenced by those around him?
Quote from: Dr.Feelgood on April 17, 2012, 03:53:12 PMIN SUMMARY : Peter Grant is a total TWAT. (You only have to sit behind the Dugout & watch him to know that.)Interesting. For the rest of us that do not sit behind the dugout can you expand on this? What is it he does that makes him a “twat”. For example how is his behaviour different to say Sid? Can you actually hear what they’re saying/instructing? * I initially typed Doug Out!, it just feels so natural.He barks orders (especially at the younger players) WAY too much. I'm not for a lack of animated enthusiasm / giudance / encouragement ( as per O'Dreary / Houllier) but IF they have been 'instructed / coached' PROPERLYin the week - PROFESSIONAL footballers should NOT need to be issued constant instruction. The odd 'tweak' forsure (in reply to opposition) but this guy is INEPT. Several times we have seen Bannan get a bollocking (for nogood reason) & he just switches off. The players clearly have little respect / regard for PG & he's counterproductive.(In my opinion - and I am not alone). And WHY NOT a man (Gabby ?) on the half way line when there's a corner ??
Quote from: Dante Lavelli on April 17, 2012, 04:04:53 PMQuote from: Dr.Feelgood on April 17, 2012, 03:53:12 PMIN SUMMARY : Peter Grant is a total TWAT. (You only have to sit behind the Dugout & watch him to know that.)Interesting. For the rest of us that do not sit behind the dugout can you expand on this? What is it he does that makes him a “twat”. For example how is his behaviour different to say Sid? Can you actually hear what they’re saying/instructing? * I initially typed Doug Out!, it just feels so natural.He barks orders (especially at the younger players) WAY too much. I'm not for a lack of animated enthusiasm / giudance / encouragement ( as per O'Dreary / Houllier) but IF they have been 'instructed / coached' PROPERLYin the week - PROFESSIONAL footballers should NOT need to be issued constant instruction. The odd 'tweak' forsure (in reply to opposition) but this guy is INEPT. Several times we have seen Bannan get a bollocking (for nogood reason) & he just switches off. The players clearly have little respect / regard for PG & he's counterproductive.(In my opinion - and I am not alone). And WHY NOT a man (Gabby ?) on the half way line when there's a corner ??
I read on other sites that the Grants orders on the touchline are too much.What you sa about Bannan doesn't surprise me he looks half the player he did last season.