Do you have ANY faith left in McLeish ?

[andyh]

Previous polls have shown that AM still has some backing amongst supporters. The argument for has always been that he needs  time and money to build his own squad and should be given a chance to do that. I think it was up around 17% - 20%, backing him last time we had a poll.

But, there does seem to have been a shift recently and its difficult to see anyone backing him...at all.

So, my question is does ANYONE still have faith that he is the right man for the job, if he was given the resources or should he walk, regardless.     

MODS - if this is a Mcleish thread too far, then delete if necessary. 

[Summers]

No.

[dutchvilla]

You cannot lose what you never had.

[VillaAlways]

None whatsoever Even if he bought good players in, he would turn them into crap ones  soon enough with his negativity.We are talking about a manager who has managed to blunt one of the most prolific strikers in the PL who scored for fun at bloody Charlton

[Mazrim]

No. None at all.

[Breezeblock]

Nope!

[eastie]

No- sack him now!

[ktvillan]

Unfortunately his safety first, negative, beaten-before-you've-started mindset is the sure mark of someone who will never, ever be a winner.  Which means there is absolutely zero point in backing him or giving him further chances.

[Mister E]

Another thread - and No!

[Dave Javu]

Yes.

[Dave Cooper please]

Oh fucking goody, another McLeish thread.
Could you not have found one of the other 533 we already have and asked this question?

[andyh]

Oh fucking goody, another McLeish thread.
Could you not have found one of the other 533 we already have and asked this question?

so why bother fucking posting in it then !

[nigel]

I have always said he has to be given time.
 
I do feel it was the wrong move by Randy, an unpopular choice with very little chance of success given the constraints he'd have to work under.
But, he still came, despite all the constraints, that took some balls. And I feel that is the reason why he must be given time, not endless, but he must have the chance to build his team and not be expected to be using MO'Ns players 5 years on.
Personally I'd say until Christmas next season. By then his team should be in place and if we're struggling then maybe that will be the time for Randy to decide.

[VillaAlways]

Please don't lock it I know for a fact they have people constantly reading the messageboard at Villa .They need to know the strength of feeling. The more the merrier

[eastie]

Nigel, dont feel sorry for mcleish , he is on good wages here and will get a good payoff for making a pigs ear of the job- shambolic!