To be honest our record so far this season has been average, he certainly hasn't got us playing above ourselves like MON managed on ocassion.
We're probably a couple of points lower than I'd have predicted (one point in two home games against the Dingles and the Baggies is nothing short of shite). I did think we'd be better at defending leads but the jury is still out on that. Come the end of December we'll have a good idea of his merits as our manager this season.
Although all valid points, you have to go back to the old 'you can only beat what is in front of you' frame of mind. Yes, I know we've only actually beaten 3 teams, but when you factor in games against two of the present top 4 and tricky away fixtures like Everton, the only really disappointing result for me was Wolves. OK, WBA also, but we were pretty much done in by a poor ref's decision and certainly think we wouldn't have lost without that.
We'll need to improve to take any significant points from the games coming up, but that doesn't take away from the good start he's had as Villa manager.