Cheers for posting this, GV, very interesting - especially commentaries - and I've not seen before. I am fortunate to have badge no 5 on the pre-1940's page from the 1924 English Cup Final. This was passed on to me by my grandfather, who was an avid Villa fan, before he died in 1969; it is silver, and appropriately hallmarked. I also have badge no 13 from the 1940's-1960's page, from the 1957 F.A. Cup Final - this was kindly gifted to me by a customer in the jewellery quarter in the mid-1980's.