Craig Gardner

[Rip Van We Go Again]

Not good enough then, not good enough now.

No ta.

[TheTimVilla]

He should have stayed and fought for his place. He didn't so no thanks. He was better than Gavin McCann but he's not better than Delph, Makoun, etc.

[Rick_avfc]

the only decent thing he has on him is a shot, hence why he managed to score so many last season

[Archbishop Herbert Cockthrottle]

I'd prefer Craig Charles and his crack pipe.

That's no way to smoke is it?

[TheSandman]

I accidentally voted yes. I mean he is a decent enough player and I'd have liked him to have stayed and get more of a chance but we have enough forward thinking midfielders so I don't want him back but I concede he is a good player.

I don't want us to sign Milner or Barton for the same reason.

[ktvillan]

Thought he was good and good enough when here, and I agree with Wilshere, he's proved it by scoring as many as he did in a crap side.  Hoewever I think he burned his bridges with us with his "always a bluenose" comments when he left.

[olaftab]

Rubbish thread.

[andyh]

Rubbish thread.

Agreed, especially when 8 people think 'Craig Gardner is a great player'.
 

[SoccerHQ]

I like Craig Gardner as a player. I was very disappointed when we sold him, but kept the likes of Sidwell.
Gardner could do a very good job for us, he has improved. Not sure I want him back because his mouth was working overtime once he'd crossed the border.

Same for me.

[Dave Cooper please]

There didn't seem to be an option for those of us who think he's a decent enough player and don't think he's a ******.

[Hadley83]

I replied to his Twitter comment (Tweet??) by saying, no disrespect but I really hope we don't resign him. Still awaiting his response. Wilshere also made comments about hoping Harry Forrester does well after leaving us and felt sorry for him not getting a chance. Would like to see Gary get a chance this year though, heard alot of promising things.

[pooligan]

No thank you, not good enough when he left,not good enough now.

[The Left Side]

No thanks he can go to Sunderland or stay in the championship.

[PaulTheVillan]

There didn't seem to be an option for those of us who think he's a decent enough player and don't think he's a c***.

I know.

[taylorsworkrate]

Why no option for:

"Decent player, not the sort of quality we should be looking at though?"